Discussion:
These people didn't care hams help with emergency services
(too old to reply)
radioguy
2009-01-10 09:04:48 UTC
Permalink
These people didn't care that hams help provide emergency services.

They still wanted the ham tower completely gone.

I wonder who won. Click on

http://74.125.95.132/search?q=cache:aCVpkB3Ki2oJ:www.antennazoning.com/docs/N1CIV-060105-Valley-News.pdf+%22ham+radio%22%2B%22interference%22%2B%22neighbors%22&hl=en&ct=clnk&cd=50&gl=us
Brenda Ann
2009-01-10 10:08:30 UTC
Permalink
Post by radioguy
These people didn't care that hams help provide emergency services.
They still wanted the ham tower completely gone.
I wonder who won. Click on
http://74.125.95.132/search?q=cache:aCVpkB3Ki2oJ:www.antennazoning.com/docs/N1CIV-060105-Valley-News.pdf+%22ham+radio%22%2B%22interference%22%2B%22neighbors%22&hl=en&ct=clnk&cd=50&gl=us
Don't know.. but in a couple months, their TVI gripe will hold no water at
all.
KC8QJP
2009-01-10 13:07:45 UTC
Permalink
Post by Brenda Ann
Post by radioguy
These people didn't care that hams help provide emergency services.
They still wanted the ham tower completely gone.
I wonder who won. Click on
http://74.125.95.132/search?q=cache:aCVpkB3Ki2oJ:www.antennazoning.com/docs/N1CIV-060105-Valley-News.pdf+%22ham+radio%22%2B%22interference%22%2B%22neighbors%22&hl=en&ct=clnk&cd=50&gl=us
Don't know.. but in a couple months, their TVI gripe will hold no water at
all.
they may turn off my electricity sooner than that ;(
m***@yahoo.com
2009-01-21 15:28:54 UTC
Permalink
Post by Brenda Ann
Post by radioguy
These people didn't care that hams help provide emergency services.
They still wanted the ham tower completely gone.
I wonder who won. Click on
http://74.125.95.132/search?q=cache:aCVpkB3Ki2oJ:www.antennazoning.co...
Don't know.. but in a couple months, their TVI gripe will hold no water at
all.
they may turn off my electricity sooner than that ;(- Hide quoted text -
- Show quoted text -
A measure recently taken that will have repercussions that will
indicate exactly how severely your actions have impacted upon fellow
keyclowns.

This measure was taken in your honor. You'll be hearing about it, but
not from us.
RF BURNS
2009-01-21 18:35:45 UTC
Permalink
Post by Brenda Ann
Post by radioguy
These people didn't care that hams help provide emergency services.
They still wanted the ham tower completely gone.
I wonder who won. Click on
http://74.125.95.132/search?q=cache:aCVpkB3Ki2oJ:www.antennazoning.co...
Don't know.. but in a couple months, their TVI gripe will hold no water at
all.
they may turn off my electricity sooner than that ;(- Hide quoted text -
- Show quoted text -
A measure recently taken that will have repercussions that will
indicate exactly how severely your actions have impacted upon fellow
keyclowns.
This measure was taken in your honor. You'll be hearing about it, but
not from us.
http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&q=KC8QJP&btnG=Google+Search&aq=f&oq=


UH OH KC8QJP IS IN EVEN MORE TROUBLE????
CRISCO KATHY BETTER WISE UP ALREADY!!!!
radioguy
2009-01-10 18:42:03 UTC
Permalink
Post by Brenda Ann
Post by radioguy
These people didn't care that hams help provide emergency services.
They still wanted the ham tower completely gone.
I wonder who won. Click on
http://74.125.95.132/search?q=cache:aCVpkB3Ki2oJ:www.antennazoning.co...
Don't know.. but in a couple months, their TVI gripe will hold no water at
all.
actually, in a cople of months, those type of people will complain
that the reason they are no longer getting any tv reception at all is
because
of all the ham radio operators.
radioguy
2009-01-15 07:19:04 UTC
Permalink
Post by Brenda Ann
Post by radioguy
These people didn't care that hams help provide emergency services.
They still wanted the ham tower completely gone.
I wonder who won. Click on
http://74.125.95.132/search?q=cache:aCVpkB3Ki2oJ:www.antennazoning.co...
Don't know.. but in a couple months, their TVI gripe will hold no water at
After thinking about it, I disagree that hams helping provide
emergencu is just an excuse.

It isn'tes

there have been many times in the past when everyone's electricity
goes out here.

And it's still very common here.

When the electric goes out, and stays out for any lengthy amount of
time,

1. you will not be ablr to use your satellite phone since there will
be no way for you to recharge it without using electricity.

2. FRS here only goes one mile at the most. I have several different
expensive brands of frs radios.

Somee only go half a mile here.

3. While CB is and can be usedul, good luck trying to get through the
local idiot here who likes to get on all the cb channels with high
power and
sat four letter words every other word in every sentence he says and
makes lewd x-rated comments and other just plain disgusting things,.
he especially enjoys getting on channel 19 and messing with all the
truckers by doing such..

Although I have heard him on other channels as well.

4. Cell phones. I heard they're usually the first to go dead during an
emergency.

5. regular telephones. While they can work without electricity to our
house out, they can also go dead if the emergency takes out the phone
system also.

Radio is the only for sure reliable way in an emergency.

That is, You never know when everything else might go out.

Radio is the only thing you can count on thatt won't go out in an
emergency.
radioguy
2009-01-15 07:25:34 UTC
Permalink
Post by Brenda Ann
Post by radioguy
These people didn't care that hams help provide emergency services.
They still wanted the ham tower completely gone.
I wonder who won. Click on
http://74.125.95.132/search?q=cache:aCVpkB3Ki2oJ:www.antennazoning.co...
Don't know.. but in a couple months, their TVI gripe will hold no water at
all.
oh, and those little emergency radio tv sets you all have. the tv
portion won't be any good for regular broadcasts after next month.
(there are not any lptv tstations or translators that can be picked up
from here and even if there were, they don't transmit very far even
with a good outdoor roof antenna for a reciever.)

And those will probably eventually switch to digital also.

And even the radio stations are already in the process of switching to
digital hd radio.

So all your crank-up emergency radios and portable battery operated tv
sets and radios will all eventually be useless for recieving regular
tv and radio broadcasts.


While ham radio and tv will and can remain for now.
Brenda Ann
2009-01-15 10:46:48 UTC
Permalink
"radioguy" <***@yahoo.com> wrote in message news:6f16947b-2885-4787-b4bf-***@l16g2000yqo.googlegroups.com...

oh, and those little emergency radio tv sets you all have. the tv
portion won't be any good for regular broadcasts after next month.
(there are not any lptv tstations or translators that can be picked up
from here and even if there were, they don't transmit very far even
with a good outdoor roof antenna for a reciever.)

And those will probably eventually switch to digital also.

And even the radio stations are already in the process of switching to
digital hd radio.

So all your crank-up emergency radios and portable battery operated tv
sets and radios will all eventually be useless for recieving regular
tv and radio broadcasts.


They'll still receive radio for quite some time.

Our government is already giving voice to delaying the analog TV shutoff
date, because they've run out of money for the converter coupon plan, and
there are still millions that won't have any television at all when the
analog is shut down. They're trying to figure out what to do about all
that..
Dave
2009-01-15 13:15:16 UTC
Permalink
Post by Brenda Ann
Our government is already giving voice to delaying the analog TV shutoff
date, because they've run out of money for the converter coupon plan, and
there are still millions that won't have any television at all when the
analog is shut down. They're trying to figure out what to do about all
that..
What a bunch of pussies! We've known it's going to hurt when it
happens. Just do it!
Joe
2009-01-10 14:07:29 UTC
Permalink
Post by radioguy
These people didn't care that hams help provide emergency services.
They still wanted the ham tower completely gone.
I wonder who won. Click on
http://74.125.95.132/search?q=cache:aCVpkB3Ki2oJ:www.antennazoning.co...
Lets be honest here and not confuse the desire to erect and use large
antenna structures to facilitate DX'ing and other radio pursuits with
the proposition of providing 'emergency communications'. I would
guess that 99.9% of the ham population never has or ever will provide
the types of 'emergency communications' to which you refer in support
of the erection of large towers and antenna arrays in deference to
zoning restrictions. Even while a vast majority continually chase the
holy grail of possessing a 'Big Gun' signal on the air. The argument
sounds great till you actually tune around the bands during normal,
every day activity and maybe once in a while during a real emergency.
What you hear is the daily 'playing' of big gun radio operation.
Excessive power, excessive bandwidth used and nothing short of
electronic bullying/boasting of my signal is bigger than your signal.
When an emergency does occur a relatively small number of big gun
stations (usually located away from the big cities on large tracts of
expensive, desirable out of the way land where restrictions and
covenants do not even come into play) handling the brunt of the
communications. And a few passersbyes who may just listen or possibly
check in to alternate 'controll the onlookers' nets, so they can tell
their buddys and the uninitiated that they were helping out with one
disaster or another before they get bored with the whole thing and
move on to the latest must have dx or contest contact.
Lets be real. Nothing wrong with Dx'ing and Contesting or any other
facet of the hobby. But know that these are the real reason behind
many off the cuff fan the flame posts in support of knocking down
zoning rules and not a 'real' desire to provide an at the ready
emergency communications setup.
Been around long enough to know that truth!
Dave
2009-01-10 15:03:16 UTC
Permalink
Post by Joe
Post by radioguy
These people didn't care that hams help provide emergency services.
They still wanted the ham tower completely gone.
I wonder who won. Click on
I would
guess that 99.9% of the ham population never has or ever will provide
the types of 'emergency communications' to which you refer...
So?

The point is that the more hams there are the more likely that the 1-out
-of-a-thousand that you refer to is in a place where he can do some good
if an emergency breaks out.
radioguy
2009-01-17 14:27:13 UTC
Permalink
Post by Dave
Post by Joe
Post by radioguy
These people didn't care that hams help provide emergency services.
They still wanted the ham tower completely gone.
I wonder who won. Click on
I would
guess that 99.9% of the ham population never has or ever will provide
the types of 'emergency communications' to which you refer...
So?
The point is that the more hams there are the more likely that the 1-out
-of-a-thousand that you refer to is in a place where he can do some good
  if an emergency breaks out.
Correct. Unlike the poster who said all that is neede isone or a few
hams in a very rural area. I did plan on moving to a rural area,
then I found out
that hams don't like hams operating from rural areas because whenever
they use any one of the nearest repeaters to them, they always
simultaneously open up all the nearest repeaters to them that have the
same CTCSS code on the same frequency they're operating on.

A rural ham who intenionally opens up the nearest repeater, a hundred
miles north of him with a ctcss code of 100.0 also unintentiomnally
opens up
the repeater 100 miles south of him that also uses a ctcss of 100.0,
the repeater 100 miles west of him also using 100.0,the repeater 100
miles east
of him using 100.0, the repeater 100 miles northeast of him using
100.0,the repeater 100miles northwest of him,the repeater 100 miles
southeast of him,
and a repeater 100 miles southwest ofhim.
radioguy
2009-01-17 14:43:33 UTC
Permalink
Post by radioguy
Post by Dave
Post by Joe
Post by radioguy
These people didn't care that hams help provide emergency services.
They still wanted the ham tower completely gone.
I wonder who won. Click on
I would
guess that 99.9% of the ham population never has or ever will provide
the types of 'emergency communications' to which you refer...
So?
The point is that the more hams there are the more likely that the 1-out
-of-a-thousand that you refer to is in a place where he can do some good
  if an emergency breaks out.
Correct. Unlike the poster who said all that is neede isone or a few
hams in a very rural area.   I did plan on moving to a rural area,
then I found out
that hams don't like hams operating from rural areas because whenever
they use any one of the nearest repeaters to them, they always
simultaneously open up all the nearest repeaters to them that have the
same CTCSS code on the same frequency they're operating on.
A rural ham who intenionally opens up the nearest repeater, a hundred
miles north of him on with a ctcss code of 100.0 also unintentiomnally
opens up
the repeater 100 miles south of him othat also uses a ctcss of 100.0on the same frequency,
the repeater 100 miles west of him on the same frequncy also using 100.0,the repeater 100
miles east
of him on the same frequency using 100.0, the repeater 100 miles northeast of him using
100.0,the repeater 100miles northwest of him,the repeater 100 miles
southeast of him,
and a repeater 100 miles southwest ofhim.- Hide quoted text -
I don't know why there's all this dsiscrimination everywhere of
people livingin rural areas.

And it's not just with ham radio either.
Post by radioguy
- Show quoted text -
James
2009-01-17 15:35:54 UTC
Permalink
jabber,
jabber,
jabber,
jabber,
jabber,
jabber,
jabber,
jabber,

--------------------------
a hundred
miles north of him with a ctcss code of 100.0 also unintentiomnally
opens up
the repeater 100 miles south of him that also uses a ctcss of 100.0,
the repeater 100 miles west of him also using 100.0,the repeater 100
miles east
of him using 100.0, the repeater 100 miles northeast of him using
100.0,the repeater 100miles northwest of him,the repeater 100 miles
southeast of him,
and a repeater 100 miles southwest ofhim.
Jim Hampton
2009-01-18 17:48:54 UTC
Permalink
Hello gang,

That would only happen if the other repeaters were also on the same
frequency. Not going to happen unless you are flying a private aircraft
several thousand feet up. Then folks will get unhappy.

This is why repeaters are supposed to be coordinated.


73 from Rochester, NY
Jim
Post by Dave
Post by Joe
Post by radioguy
These people didn't care that hams help provide emergency services.
They still wanted the ham tower completely gone.
I wonder who won. Click on
I would
guess that 99.9% of the ham population never has or ever will provide
the types of 'emergency communications' to which you refer...
So?
The point is that the more hams there are the more likely that the 1-out
-of-a-thousand that you refer to is in a place where he can do some good
if an emergency breaks out.
Correct. Unlike the poster who said all that is neede isone or a few
hams in a very rural area. I did plan on moving to a rural area,
then I found out
that hams don't like hams operating from rural areas because whenever
they use any one of the nearest repeaters to them, they always
simultaneously open up all the nearest repeaters to them that have the
same CTCSS code on the same frequency they're operating on.

A rural ham who intenionally opens up the nearest repeater, a hundred
miles north of him with a ctcss code of 100.0 also unintentiomnally
opens up
the repeater 100 miles south of him that also uses a ctcss of 100.0,
the repeater 100 miles west of him also using 100.0,the repeater 100
miles east
of him using 100.0, the repeater 100 miles northeast of him using
100.0,the repeater 100miles northwest of him,the repeater 100 miles
southeast of him,
and a repeater 100 miles southwest ofhim.
RHF
2009-01-18 18:45:52 UTC
Permalink
Post by Jim Hampton
Hello gang,
That would only happen if the other repeaters were also on the same
frequency.  Not going to happen unless you are flying a private aircraft
several thousand feet up.  Then folks will get unhappy.
This is why repeaters are supposed to be coordinated.
73 from Rochester, NY
Post by Dave
Post by Joe
Post by radioguy
These people didn't care that hams help provide emergency services.
They still wanted the ham tower completely gone.
I wonder who won. Click on
I would
guess that 99.9% of the ham population never has or ever will provide
the types of 'emergency communications' to which you refer...
So?
The point is that the more hams there are the more likely that the 1-out
-of-a-thousand that you refer to is in a place where he can do some good
if an emergency breaks out.
Correct. Unlike the poster who said all that is neede isone or a few
hams in a very rural area.   I did plan on moving to a rural area,
then I found out
that hams don't like hams operating from rural areas because whenever
they use any one of the nearest repeaters to them, they always
simultaneously open up all the nearest repeaters to them that have the
same CTCSS code on the same frequency they're operating on.
A rural ham who intenionally opens up the nearest repeater, a hundred
miles north of him with a ctcss code of 100.0 also unintentiomnally
opens up
the repeater 100 miles south of him that also uses a ctcss of 100.0,
the repeater 100 miles west of him also using 100.0,the repeater 100
miles east
of him using 100.0, the repeater 100 miles northeast of him using
100.0,the repeater 100miles northwest of him,the repeater 100 miles
southeast of him,
and a repeater 100 miles southwest ofhim.
Yeah - It's just another RadioGuy "Troll Story"

How many 'made-up' Amateur Radio Operator
problems can you fit on the head of a pin ? ? ?

just ask RadioGuy ;;-{ ~ RHF
.
d***@gmail.com
2009-01-27 21:54:40 UTC
Permalink
On Sun, 18 Jan 2009 10:45:52 -0800 (PST), RHF
Post by RHF
Post by Jim Hampton
Hello gang,
That would only happen if the other repeaters were also on the same
frequency.  Not going to happen unless you are flying a private aircraft
several thousand feet up.  Then folks will get unhappy.
This is why repeaters are supposed to be coordinated.
73 from Rochester, NY
Post by Dave
Post by Joe
Post by radioguy
These people didn't care that hams help provide emergency services.
They still wanted the ham tower completely gone.
I wonder who won. Click on
I would
guess that 99.9% of the ham population never has or ever will provide
the types of 'emergency communications' to which you refer...
So?
The point is that the more hams there are the more likely that the 1-out
-of-a-thousand that you refer to is in a place where he can do some good
if an emergency breaks out.
Correct. Unlike the poster who said all that is neede isone or a few
hams in a very rural area.   I did plan on moving to a rural area,
then I found out
that hams don't like hams operating from rural areas because whenever
they use any one of the nearest repeaters to them, they always
simultaneously open up all the nearest repeaters to them that have the
same CTCSS code on the same frequency they're operating on.
A rural ham who intenionally opens up the nearest repeater, a hundred
miles north of him with a ctcss code of 100.0 also unintentiomnally
opens up
the repeater 100 miles south of him that also uses a ctcss of 100.0,
the repeater 100 miles west of him also using 100.0,the repeater 100
miles east
of him using 100.0, the repeater 100 miles northeast of him using
100.0,the repeater 100miles northwest of him,the repeater 100 miles
southeast of him,
and a repeater 100 miles southwest ofhim.
Yeah - It's just another RadioGuy "Troll Story"
How many 'made-up' Amateur Radio Operator
problems can you fit on the head of a pin ? ? ?
just ask RadioGuy ;;-{ ~ RHF
.
radioguy
2009-01-10 18:48:23 UTC
Permalink
Post by Joe
Post by radioguy
They still wanted the ham tower completely gone.
I wonder who won. Click on
http://74.125.95.132/search?q=cache:aCVpkB3Ki2oJ:www.antennazoning.co...
Lets be honest here and not confuse the desire to erect and use large
antenna structures to facilitate DX'ing and other radio pursuits with
the proposition of providing 'emergency communications'.  I would
guess that 99.9% of the ham population never has or ever will provide
the types of 'emergency communications' to which you refer in support
of the erection of large towers and antenna arrays in deference to
zoning restrictions. Even while a vast majority continually chase the
holy grail of possessing a 'Big Gun' signal on the air.  The argument
sounds great till you actually tune around the bands during normal,
every day activity and maybe once in a while during a real emergency.
What you hear is the daily 'playing' of big gun radio operation.
Excessive power, excessive bandwidth used and nothing short of
electronic bullying/boasting of my signal is bigger than your signal.
When an emergency does occur a relatively small number of big gun
stations (usually located away from the big cities on large tracts of
expensive, desirable out of the way land where restrictions and
covenants do not even come into play) handling the brunt of the
communications. And a few passersbyes who may just listen or possibly
check in to alternate 'controll the onlookers' nets, so they can tell
their buddys and the uninitiated that they were helping out with one
disaster or another before they get bored with the whole thing and
move on to the latest must have dx or contest contact.
Lets be real.  Nothing wrong with Dx'ing and Contesting or any other
facet of the hobby.  But know that these are the real reason behind
many off the cuff fan the flame posts in support of knocking down
zoning rules and not a 'real' desire to provide an at the ready
emergency communications setup.
Been around long enough to know that truth!
While you're correct, that was the excuse the ham in the article used.
At least according to the article.

I never noticed any excessive bandwidth hogging on ham radio. Unless
it's either the hi-fi ssb I heard about which the FCC was illegal
aince it was hogging the bandwidth. However, if that's so, then that
also makes using AM on ham radio illegal.

And several people still use AM mode on ham radio.

Or unless it's using FM on 2 meters and 70 centimeters where an AM
signal would take up much less space.
Telamon
2009-01-10 23:34:32 UTC
Permalink
In article
Post by radioguy
Post by radioguy
didn't care that hams help provide emergency services.
Post by radioguy
They still wanted the ham tower completely gone.
I wonder who won. Click on
http://74.125.95.132/search?q=cache:aCVpkB3Ki2oJ:www.antennazoning.co...
Lets be honest here and not confuse the desire to erect and use
large antenna structures to facilitate DX'ing and other radio
pursuits with the proposition of providing 'emergency
communications'.  I would guess that 99.9% of the ham population
never has or ever will provide the types of 'emergency
communications' to which you refer in support of the erection of
large towers and antenna arrays in deference to zoning
restrictions. Even while a vast majority continually chase the holy
grail of possessing a 'Big Gun' signal on the air.  The argument
sounds great till you actually tune around the bands during normal,
every day activity and maybe once in a while during a real
emergency. What you hear is the daily 'playing' of big gun radio
operation. Excessive power, excessive bandwidth used and nothing
short of electronic bullying/boasting of my signal is bigger than
your signal. When an emergency does occur a relatively small number
of big gun stations (usually located away from the big cities on
large tracts of expensive, desirable out of the way land where
restrictions and covenants do not even come into play) handling the
brunt of the communications. And a few passersbyes who may just
listen or possibly check in to alternate 'controll the onlookers'
nets, so they can tell their buddys and the uninitiated that they
were helping out with one disaster or another before they get bored
with the whole thing and move on to the latest must have dx or
contest contact. Lets be real.  Nothing wrong with Dx'ing and
Contesting or any other facet of the hobby.  But know that these
are the real reason behind many off the cuff fan the flame posts in
support of knocking down zoning rules and not a 'real' desire to
provide an at the ready emergency communications setup. Been around
long enough to know that truth!
While you're correct, that was the excuse the ham in the article
used. At least according to the article.
I never noticed any excessive bandwidth hogging on ham radio. Unless
it's either the hi-fi ssb I heard about which the FCC was illegal
aince it was hogging the bandwidth. However, if that's so, then that
also makes using AM on ham radio illegal.
And several people still use AM mode on ham radio.
Or unless it's using FM on 2 meters and 70 centimeters where an AM
signal would take up much less space.
Why don't you guys ever bring up the technology? The original reason
the government wanted to license the public to use the spectrum was for
the general public to be able to use the communications technology that
drives the economy and provides people with useful skills for the armed
services. The government has always recognized this as a way to
encourage citizens to become familure with electronics and
communications technologies.

The complete ass-backward thinking in this country started with denying
citizens utilization of natural resources over the last couple of
decades and now is extended to the use of technology. Now we are just
supposed to be users of technology that we have to buy from other third
world countries.

This retarded natural resource thinking has now cumulated into "global
warming" BS spewed by the resource hog AL Utterly Boring Gore and Ham
operators are just good consumers these days.

We are just setting ourselves up for a fall.
--
Telamon
Ventura, California
Steve Stone
2009-01-11 19:35:31 UTC
Permalink
Post by Telamon
The complete ass-backward thinking in this country started with denying
citizens utilization of natural resources over the last couple of
decades and now is extended to the use of technology. Now we are just
supposed to be users of technology that we have to buy from other third
world countries.
I saw it start in the early 1970's.
Many people who liked to weekend tinker with electronics on their bench,
build kits, etc., were turned off by the complexity
of IC's and the density of parts stuffed on a single board, combined
with cheap stuff from overseas.
The hobby magazines of the times got hooked on early build it yourself
computer projects. It was over the heads of many who liked to play.
SC Dxing
2009-01-11 01:11:57 UTC
Permalink
Post by Joe
Lets be real.  Nothing wrong with Dx'ing and Contesting or any other
facet of the hobby.  But know that these are the real reason behind
many off the cuff fan the flame posts in support of knocking down
zoning rules
Agree with Joe. The emergency communication thing is just and excuse.
If they really want something that can help during an emergency, they
should buy a satellite phone. Would also be a lot of cheaper. They've
already got a 40 foot high antenna which is more than adequate for
emergency communications in the Hartford area.
RHF
2009-01-11 20:23:33 UTC
Permalink
Post by SC Dxing
Post by Joe
Lets be real.  Nothing wrong with Dx'ing and Contesting or any other
facet of the hobby.  But know that these are the real reason behind
many off the cuff fan the flame posts in support of knocking down
zoning rules
Agree with Joe. The emergency communication thing is just and excuse.
If they really want something that can help during an emergency, they
should buy a satellite phone. Would also be a lot of cheaper. They've
already got a 40 foot high antenna which is more than adequate for
emergency communications in the Hartford area.
Extend the existing 40-Foot Radio Tower up to a
93-Foot Tower [Structure] topped off with a 10-Foot
Antenna for a total of 103-Foot high on top of a hill.

sounds more like a towering monument to
someone's personal status and ego ~ RHF
.
SC Dxing
2009-01-11 21:41:27 UTC
Permalink
Post by RHF
sounds more like a towering monument to
someone's personal status and ego ~ RHF
 .
Agreed. There was a time when a HAM radio operator was a real asset in
a disaster. But with the advances in technology, especially portable
communications, those days have passed.
d***@hotmail.com
2009-01-12 00:00:24 UTC
Permalink
Post by SC Dxing
A hurricane/snow storm can easily take out any antenna tower.
So me evidence to back up your claims. I've had multiple towers in
many locations and I've never lost one to a snow storm, ice storm,
hurricane, or tornado. Usually, the tower is the one thing that
survives.
Post by SC Dxing
Then you need electricity
Generators are fairly plentiful and run for days on 200 gallons of
propane.
Post by SC Dxing
Then you need someone who is going to listen on the
other side.
And hams do listen 24/7, somewhere in the world someone is always
listening. During Katrina, thounsands of traffic messages were passed,
as has many messages been handled during a lot of the ice storms this
season up North.
Post by SC Dxing
My wife works for emergency services and not a single
emergency scenario involves using ham radio operators.
Then they are not utilizing all the resources available to them.
Thankfully, my community involves all legitimate parties during every
emergency exercise, including ham radio ops, but CB radio and FRS are
never included because the folks who own FRS want to have a family CB
service, and CB radio ops are too busy trying to play who has the
biggest illegal amplfier. The users of CB and FRS do not have an
interest in emergency coms until something happens, then they show up
untrained, uncoordinated, and become an hinderance to any on going
operations.
Post by SC Dxing
If anything, CB radio or mobile UHF/VHF device would be more reliable.
Hams use UHF and VHF, so your point is??? And mobile CB is useless
more than 5-10 miles away unless you are running illegal power.
Post by SC Dxing
And a stationary HAM radio can only be used in one location.
And can relay messages locally from roving ops checking on health and
welfare, as well Statewide, Country wide, and World wide. Don't
forget that hams work in coordination with each other, some mobile,
and someone at the base with a tower relaying the information locally
or statewide as necessary.
Post by SC Dxing
Not very good, if you are going around house to house checking on people in an
emergency.
But ham radio can be used both portable and base, a repeater statioin
also comes to mind as a coordinated effort that has proven itself time
and time again.
Post by SC Dxing
A stationary tower is probably the worst choice for
emergency communications.
Why. Every emergeny service in the US uses stationary stations with
towers as the hub to their operations.
Post by SC Dxing
Satellite phone. Never ever goes out as long as you got it charged.
Never.
Most folks are not going to pay the outlandish monthly fees for a
satellite phone + air time. The only reason your sat phone works is
because not many folks have them. Just imagine if everyone had a sat
phone instead of a cell phone. I can tell you from experience that on
September 11, the whole cell phone infrastructure crashed and was not
operable.

If everyone had sat phones, it would overload the capablility of the
sat, and your phone would be worthless.
Post by SC Dxing
Post by RHF
sounds more like a towering monument to
someone's personal status and ego ~ RHF
�.
Agreed. There was a time when a HAM radio operator was a real asset in
a disaster. But with the advances in technology, especially portable
communications, those days have passed.
So where were all of the so called advances when Katrina took out the
Gulf Coast? Or during the recent ice storms up North. Hams have
activiely assisted on both events and every major emergency in
between.

BTW, Which emergency organization does your wife work for, I would
like to find out why they are not adhering to the policies set forth
in the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) 2007 Appropriations Act
(HR 5441). Which indicates that Amateur Radio should be incorperated
into the contingent plans by all communities for emergency and
disaster prepardness.

DL
an_old_friend
2009-01-12 00:43:16 UTC
Permalink
Post by d***@hotmail.com
Post by SC Dxing
A hurricane/snow storm can easily take out any antenna tower.
So me evidence to back up your claims. I've had multiple towers in
many locations and I've never lost one to a snow storm, ice storm,
hurricane, or tornado.  Usually, the tower is the one thing that
survives.
Post by SC Dxing
Then you need electricity
Generators are fairly plentiful and run for days on 200 gallons of
propane.
when you p[laning on geting a ham licernse DL?
d***@hotmail.com
2009-01-12 01:27:56 UTC
Permalink
Post by an_old_friend
when you p[laning on geting a ham licernse DL?
I've had one for years. Extra class since 1997.
no evidence you have even a tech dl  stop the lies in the new years oh
unlienced fraud
Plenty of evidence Mark, just go look on QRZ, buckmaster, or one of
the other sites. I'm on there.
d***@hotmail.com
2009-01-12 01:02:50 UTC
Permalink
Post by an_old_friend
Post by d***@hotmail.com
Post by SC Dxing
A hurricane/snow storm can easily take out any antenna tower.
So me evidence to back up your claims. I've had multiple towers in
many locations and I've never lost one to a snow storm, ice storm,
hurricane, or tornado.  Usually, the tower is the one thing that
survives.
Post by SC Dxing
Then you need electricity
Generators are fairly plentiful and run for days on 200 gallons of
propane.
when you p[laning on geting a ham licernse DL?
I've had one for years. Extra class since 1997. Why do you ask, Mark?
an_old_friend
2009-01-12 01:08:21 UTC
Permalink
Post by an_old_friend
when you p[laning on geting a ham licernse DL?
I've had one for years. Extra class since 1997.
no evidence you have even a tech dl stop the lies in the new years oh
unlienced fraud
RHF
2009-01-12 03:35:13 UTC
Permalink
Post by d***@hotmail.com
Post by SC Dxing
A hurricane/snow storm can easily take out any antenna tower.
So me evidence to back up your claims. I've had multiple towers in
many locations and I've never lost one to a snow storm, ice storm,
hurricane, or tornado.  Usually, the tower is the one thing that
survives.
Post by SC Dxing
Then you need electricity
Generators are fairly plentiful and run for days on 200 gallons of
propane.
Post by SC Dxing
Then you need someone who is going to listen on the
other side.
And hams do listen 24/7, somewhere in the world someone is always
listening. During Katrina, thounsands of traffic messages were passed,
as has many messages been handled during a lot of the ice storms this
season up North.
Post by SC Dxing
My wife works for emergency services and not a single
emergency scenario involves using ham radio operators.
Then they are not utilizing all the resources available to them.
Thankfully, my community involves all legitimate parties during every
emergency exercise, including ham radio ops, but CB radio and FRS are
never included because the folks who own FRS want to have a family CB
service, and CB radio ops are too busy trying to play who has the
biggest illegal amplfier. The users of CB and FRS do not have an
interest in emergency coms until something happens, then they show up
untrained, uncoordinated, and become an hinderance to any on going
operations.
Post by SC Dxing
If anything,  CB radio or mobile UHF/VHF device would be more reliable.
Hams use UHF and VHF, so your point is??? And mobile CB is useless
more than 5-10 miles away unless you are running illegal power.
Post by SC Dxing
And a stationary HAM radio can only be used in one location.
And can relay messages locally from roving ops checking on health and
welfare, as well Statewide, Country wide, and World wide.  Don't
forget that hams work in coordination with each other, some mobile,
and someone at the base with a tower relaying the information locally
or statewide as necessary.
Post by SC Dxing
Not very good, if you are going around house to house checking on people in an
emergency.
But ham radio can be used both portable and base, a repeater statioin
also comes to mind as a coordinated effort that has proven itself time
and time again.
Post by SC Dxing
A stationary tower is probably the worst choice for
emergency communications.
Why. Every emergeny service in the US uses stationary stations with
towers as the hub to their operations.
Post by SC Dxing
Satellite phone. Never ever goes out as long as you got it charged.
Never.
Most folks are not going to pay the outlandish monthly fees for a
satellite phone + air time.  The only reason your sat phone works is
because not many folks have them.  Just imagine if everyone had a sat
phone instead of a cell phone.  I can tell you from experience that on
September 11, the whole cell phone infrastructure crashed and was not
operable.
If everyone had sat phones, it would overload the capablility of the
sat, and your phone would be worthless.
Post by SC Dxing
Post by RHF
sounds more like a towering monument to
someone's personal status and ego ~ RHF
.
Agreed. There was a time when a HAM radio operator was a real asset in
a disaster. But with the advances in technology, especially portable
communications, those days have passed.
So where were all of the so called advances when Katrina took out the
Gulf Coast? Or during the recent ice storms up North.  Hams have
activiely assisted on both events and every major emergency in
between.
BTW, Which emergency organization does your wife work for, I would
like to find out why they are not adhering to the policies set forth
in the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) 2007 Appropriations Act
(HR 5441). Which indicates that Amateur Radio should be incorperated
into the contingent plans by all communities for emergency and
disaster prepardness.
DL
DL - You are thinking like a HAM : Who Is Prepared :
You may be able to help a few or many -but-What
about the hundreds of 'others' in need of H-E-L-P too ?

But the Average Citizen is NOT prepared : That Has
Got To Change : Putting a FRS, GMRS, and/or CB
Radio in the Hands of American Household can make
it possible to HELP Hundreds of People in Need.
Every Citizen a Neighbor and Neightbors Helping
Neighbors in their Local Neighborhoods. ~ RHF
.
d***@hotmail.com
2009-01-12 21:56:53 UTC
Permalink
Post by RHF
Post by d***@hotmail.com
Post by SC Dxing
A hurricane/snow storm can easily take out any antenna tower.
So me evidence to back up your claims. I've had multiple towers in
many locations and I've never lost one to a snow storm, ice storm,
hurricane, or tornado. �Usually, the tower is the one thing that
survives.
Post by SC Dxing
Then you need electricity
Generators are fairly plentiful and run for days on 200 gallons of
propane.
Post by SC Dxing
Then you need someone who is going to listen on the
other side.
And hams do listen 24/7, somewhere in the world someone is always
listening. During Katrina, thounsands of traffic messages were passed,
as has many messages been handled during a lot of the ice storms this
season up North.
Post by SC Dxing
My wife works for emergency services and not a single
emergency scenario involves using ham radio operators.
Then they are not utilizing all the resources available to them.
Thankfully, my community involves all legitimate parties during every
emergency exercise, including ham radio ops, but CB radio and FRS are
never included because the folks who own FRS want to have a family CB
service, and CB radio ops are too busy trying to play who has the
biggest illegal amplfier. The users of CB and FRS do not have an
interest in emergency coms until something happens, then they show up
untrained, uncoordinated, and become an hinderance to any on going
operations.
Post by SC Dxing
If anything, �CB radio or mobile UHF/VHF device would be more reliable.
Hams use UHF and VHF, so your point is??? And mobile CB is useless
more than 5-10 miles away unless you are running illegal power.
Post by SC Dxing
And a stationary HAM radio can only be used in one location.
And can relay messages locally from roving ops checking on health and
welfare, as well Statewide, Country wide, and World wide. �Don't
forget that hams work in coordination with each other, some mobile,
and someone at the base with a tower relaying the information locally
or statewide as necessary.
Post by SC Dxing
Not very good, if you are going around house to house checking on people in an
emergency.
But ham radio can be used both portable and base, a repeater statioin
also comes to mind as a coordinated effort that has proven itself time
and time again.
Post by SC Dxing
A stationary tower is probably the worst choice for
emergency communications.
Why. Every emergeny service in the US uses stationary stations with
towers as the hub to their operations.
Post by SC Dxing
Satellite phone. Never ever goes out as long as you got it charged.
Never.
Most folks are not going to pay the outlandish monthly fees for a
satellite phone + air time. �The only reason your sat phone works is
because not many folks have them. �Just imagine if everyone had a sat
phone instead of a cell phone. �I can tell you from experience that on
September 11, the whole cell phone infrastructure crashed and was not
operable.
If everyone had sat phones, it would overload the capablility of the
sat, and your phone would be worthless.
Post by SC Dxing
Post by RHF
sounds more like a towering monument to
someone's personal status and ego ~ RHF
.
Agreed. There was a time when a HAM radio operator was a real asset in
a disaster. But with the advances in technology, especially portable
communications, those days have passed.
So where were all of the so called advances when Katrina took out the
Gulf Coast? Or during the recent ice storms up North. �Hams have
activiely assisted on both events and every major emergency in
between.
BTW, Which emergency organization does your wife work for, I would
like to find out why they are not adhering to the policies set forth
in the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) 2007 Appropriations Act
(HR 5441). Which indicates that Amateur Radio should be incorperated
into the contingent plans by all communities for emergency and
disaster prepardness.
DL
You may be able to help a few or many -but-What
about the hundreds of 'others' in need of H-E-L-P too ?
But the Average Citizen is NOT prepared : That Has
Got To Change : Putting a FRS, GMRS, and/or CB
Radio in the Hands of American Household can make
it possible to HELP Hundreds of People in Need.
But RHF, why try to reinvent the wheel? The Amateur Radio Service is
alreday recognized by most emergency organizations as the go to folks
when they need additionally capacity to handle communication duties.
Putting hundreds of thousands of FRS, GMRS, and CB's into the hands
every citizen will cause nothing but jammed frequencies and an
overloaded of panicked citizens all crying out for help at the same
time. Imagine 25,000 cb radios or FRS radios all transmitting at once
crying out for help....What you would have is nothing but a garbled
mess.

The first rule of emergency comms is to have a well defined plan that
consists of already trained folks who know how to use the equipment
they have, and are trained to prioritize the comms in a useful
manner. In reality, if folks feel that strong about it having the
capability, a ham ticket is easily obtained, and there are hams whoes
only interest in ham radio is emergency comms, training for it, and
support thereof.
Post by RHF
Every Citizen a Neighbor and Neightbors Helping
Neighbors in their Local Neighborhoods. ~ RHF
And how are they going to help, who is going to be able to handle the
"all at once" radio traffic that would barrage the EC under your
scenario. Even at the local level, such at a fire station, there
would not be enough staff to handle the traffic. Imagine 5000 calls
coming in at one time.


DL
d***@hotmail.com
2009-01-12 22:10:07 UTC
Permalink
Post by RHF
Post by d***@hotmail.com
Post by SC Dxing
A hurricane/snow storm can easily take out any antenna tower.
So me evidence to back up your claims. I've had multiple towers in
many locations and I've never lost one to a snow storm, ice storm,
hurricane, or tornado. Usually, the tower is the one thing that
survives.
Post by SC Dxing
Then you need electricity
Generators are fairly plentiful and run for days on 200 gallons of
propane.
Post by SC Dxing
Then you need someone who is going to listen on the
other side.
And hams do listen 24/7, somewhere in the world someone is always
listening. During Katrina, thounsands of traffic messages were passed,
as has many messages been handled during a lot of the ice storms this
season up North.
Post by SC Dxing
My wife works for emergency services and not a single
emergency scenario involves using ham radio operators.
Then they are not utilizing all the resources available to them.
Thankfully, my community involves all legitimate parties during every
emergency exercise, including ham radio ops, but CB radio and FRS are
never included because the folks who own FRS want to have a family CB
service, and CB radio ops are too busy trying to play who has the
biggest illegal amplfier. The users of CB and FRS do not have an
interest in emergency coms until something happens, then they show up
untrained, uncoordinated, and become an hinderance to any on going
operations.
Post by SC Dxing
If anything, CB radio or mobile UHF/VHF device would be more reliable.
Hams use UHF and VHF, so your point is??? And mobile CB is useless
more than 5-10 miles away unless you are running illegal power.
Post by SC Dxing
And a stationary HAM radio can only be used in one location.
And can relay messages locally from roving ops checking on health and
welfare, as well Statewide, Country wide, and World wide. Don't
forget that hams work in coordination with each other, some mobile,
and someone at the base with a tower relaying the information locally
or statewide as necessary.
Post by SC Dxing
Not very good, if you are going around house to house checking on people in an
emergency.
But ham radio can be used both portable and base, a repeater statioin
also comes to mind as a coordinated effort that has proven itself time
and time again.
Post by SC Dxing
A stationary tower is probably the worst choice for
emergency communications.
Why. Every emergeny service in the US uses stationary stations with
towers as the hub to their operations.
Post by SC Dxing
Satellite phone. Never ever goes out as long as you got it charged.
Never.
Most folks are not going to pay the outlandish monthly fees for a
satellite phone + air time. The only reason your sat phone works is
because not many folks have them. Just imagine if everyone had a sat
phone instead of a cell phone. I can tell you from experience that on
September 11, the whole cell phone infrastructure crashed and was not
operable.
If everyone had sat phones, it would overload the capablility of the
sat, and your phone would be worthless.
Post by SC Dxing
Post by RHF
sounds more like a towering monument to
someone's personal status and ego ~ RHF
.
Agreed. There was a time when a HAM radio operator was a real asset in
a disaster. But with the advances in technology, especially portable
communications, those days have passed.
So where were all of the so called advances when Katrina took out the
Gulf Coast? Or during the recent ice storms up North. Hams have
activiely assisted on both events and every major emergency in
between.
BTW, Which emergency organization does your wife work for, I would
like to find out why they are not adhering to the policies set forth
in the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) 2007 Appropriations Act
(HR 5441). Which indicates that Amateur Radio should be incorperated
into the contingent plans by all communities for emergency and
disaster prepardness.
DL
You may be able to help a few or many -but-What
about the hundreds of 'others' in need of H-E-L-P too ?
But the Average Citizen is NOT prepared : That Has
Got To Change : Putting a FRS, GMRS, and/or CB
Radio in the Hands of American Household can make
it possible to HELP Hundreds of People in Need.
But RHF, why try to reinvent the wheel? �The Amateur Radio Service is
alreday recognized by most emergency organizations as the go to folks
when they need additionally capacity to handle communication duties.
Putting hundreds of thousands of FRS, GMRS, and CB's into the hands
every citizen will cause nothing but jammed frequencies and an
overloaded of panicked citizens all crying out for help at the same
time. Imagine 25,000 cb radios or FRS radios all transmitting at once
crying out for help....What you would have is nothing but a garbled
mess.
The first rule of emergency comms is to have a well defined plan that
consists of already trained folks who know how to use the equipment
they have, and are trained to prioritize the comms in a useful
manner. �In reality, if folks feel that strong about it having the
capability, a ham ticket is easily obtained, and there are hams whoes
only interest in ham radio is emergency comms, training for it, and
support thereof.
Post by RHF
Every Citizen a Neighbor and Neightbors Helping
Neighbors in their Local Neighborhoods. ~ RHF
And how are they going to help, who is going to be able to handle the
"all at once" radio traffic that would barrage the EC under your
scenario. �Even at the local level, such at a fire station, there
would not be enough staff to handle the traffic. Imagine 5000 calls
coming in at one time.
DL- Hide quoted text -
- Show quoted text -
I think we are beating a dead horse, but let me add this. When comes
to emergencies a well defined plan is your best defense to ensure
helping as many folk as possible, as soon as possible. When an
emergency strikes usually there is no issue of knowing who needs help,
the problem is trying to get help to those in need in a timely manner.
If you want to help out, get your ham ticket, seek out your local
RACES. Volunteer your time to receive the necessary training, and put
that training into practice by volunteering for the exercises when
they are held.

But back to the original subject of the tower height...Generally
speaking, the higher the antenna, the better the coverage, and when
you are out in the field with an HT reporting back through a repeater,
10 feet can make all the difference in the world.

73

DL
an_old_friend
2009-01-12 22:35:41 UTC
Permalink
Post by d***@hotmail.com
Post by RHF
Post by d***@hotmail.com
Post by SC Dxing
A hurricane/snow storm can easily take out any antenna tower.
So me evidence to back up your claims. I've had multiple towers in
many locations and I've never lost one to a snow storm, ice storm,
hurricane, or tornado. Usually, the tower is the one thing that
survives.
Post by SC Dxing
Then you need electricity
Generators are fairly plentiful and run for days on 200 gallons of
propane.
Post by SC Dxing
Then you need someone who is going to listen on the
other side.
And hams do listen 24/7, somewhere in the world someone is always
listening. During Katrina, thounsands of traffic messages were passed,
as has many messages been handled during a lot of the ice storms this
season up North.
Post by SC Dxing
My wife works for emergency services and not a single
emergency scenario involves using ham radio operators.
Then they are not utilizing all the resources available to them.
Thankfully, my community involves all legitimate parties during every
emergency exercise, including ham radio ops, but CB radio and FRS are
never included because the folks who own FRS want to have a family CB
service, and CB radio ops are too busy trying to play who has the
biggest illegal amplfier. The users of CB and FRS do not have an
interest in emergency coms until something happens, then they show up
untrained, uncoordinated, and become an hinderance to any on going
operations.
Post by SC Dxing
If anything, CB radio or mobile UHF/VHF device would be more reliable.
Hams use UHF and VHF, so your point is??? And mobile CB is useless
more than 5-10 miles away unless you are running illegal power.
Post by SC Dxing
And a stationary HAM radio can only be used in one location.
And can relay messages locally from roving ops checking on health and
welfare, as well Statewide, Country wide, and World wide. Don't
forget that hams work in coordination with each other, some mobile,
and someone at the base with a tower relaying the information locally
or statewide as necessary.
Post by SC Dxing
Not very good, if you are going around house to house checking on people in an
emergency.
But ham radio can be used both portable and base, a repeater statioin
also comes to mind as a coordinated effort that has proven itself time
and time again.
Post by SC Dxing
A stationary tower is probably the worst choice for
emergency communications.
Why. Every emergeny service in the US uses stationary stations with
towers as the hub to their operations.
Post by SC Dxing
Satellite phone. Never ever goes out as long as you got it charged.
Never.
Most folks are not going to pay the outlandish monthly fees for a
satellite phone + air time. The only reason your sat phone works is
because not many folks have them. Just imagine if everyone had a sat
phone instead of a cell phone. I can tell you from experience that on
September 11, the whole cell phone infrastructure crashed and was not
operable.
If everyone had sat phones, it would overload the capablility of the
sat, and your phone would be worthless.
Post by SC Dxing
Post by RHF
sounds more like a towering monument to
someone's personal status and ego ~ RHF
.
Agreed. There was a time when a HAM radio operator was a real asset in
a disaster. But with the advances in technology, especially portable
communications, those days have passed.
So where were all of the so called advances when Katrina took out the
Gulf Coast? Or during the recent ice storms up North. Hams have
activiely assisted on both events and every major emergency in
between.
BTW, Which emergency organization does your wife work for, I would
like to find out why they are not adhering to the policies set forth
in the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) 2007 Appropriations Act
(HR 5441). Which indicates that Amateur Radio should be incorperated
into the contingent plans by all communities for emergency and
disaster prepardness.
DL
You may be able to help a few or many -but-What
about the hundreds of 'others' in need of H-E-L-P too ?
But the Average Citizen is NOT prepared : That Has
Got To Change : Putting a FRS, GMRS, and/or CB
Radio in the Hands of American Household can make
it possible to HELP Hundreds of People in Need.
But RHF, why try to reinvent the wheel? The Amateur Radio Service is
alreday recognized by most emergency organizations as the go to folks
when they need additionally capacity to handle communication duties.
Putting hundreds of thousands of FRS, GMRS, and CB's into the hands
every citizen will cause nothing but jammed frequencies and an
overloaded of panicked citizens all crying out for help at the same
time. Imagine 25,000 cb radios or FRS radios all transmitting at once
crying out for help....What you would have is nothing but a garbled
mess.
The first rule of emergency comms is to have a well defined plan that
consists of already trained folks who know how to use the equipment
they have, and are trained to prioritize the comms in a useful
manner. In reality, if folks feel that strong about it having the
capability, a ham ticket is easily obtained, and there are hams whoes
only interest in ham radio is emergency comms, training for it, and
support thereof.
Post by RHF
Every Citizen a Neighbor and Neightbors Helping
Neighbors in their Local Neighborhoods. ~ RHF
And how are they going to help, who is going to be able to handle the
"all at once" radio traffic that would barrage the EC under your
scenario. Even at the local level, such at a fire station, there
would not be enough staff to handle the traffic. Imagine 5000 calls
coming in at one time.
DL- Hide quoted text -
- Show quoted text -
I think we are beating a dead horse,
then stop beating it and stop beating other dead horses lkike your
stale vendattas against me and maybe lloyd davies

you could try to act like an adult
RHF
2009-01-13 19:15:05 UTC
Permalink
Post by RHF
Post by d***@hotmail.com
Post by SC Dxing
A hurricane/snow storm can easily take out any antenna tower.
So me evidence to back up your claims. I've had multiple towers in
many locations and I've never lost one to a snow storm, ice storm,
hurricane, or tornado. Usually, the tower is the one thing that
survives.
Post by SC Dxing
Then you need electricity
Generators are fairly plentiful and run for days on 200 gallons of
propane.
Post by SC Dxing
Then you need someone who is going to listen on the
other side.
And hams do listen 24/7, somewhere in the world someone is always
listening. During Katrina, thounsands of traffic messages were passed,
as has many messages been handled during a lot of the ice storms this
season up North.
Post by SC Dxing
My wife works for emergency services and not a single
emergency scenario involves using ham radio operators.
Then they are not utilizing all the resources available to them.
Thankfully, my community involves all legitimate parties during every
emergency exercise, including ham radio ops, but CB radio and FRS are
never included because the folks who own FRS want to have a family CB
service, and CB radio ops are too busy trying to play who has the
biggest illegal amplfier. The users of CB and FRS do not have an
interest in emergency coms until something happens, then they show up
untrained, uncoordinated, and become an hinderance to any on going
operations.
Post by SC Dxing
If anything, CB radio or mobile UHF/VHF device would be more reliable.
Hams use UHF and VHF, so your point is??? And mobile CB is useless
more than 5-10 miles away unless you are running illegal power.
Post by SC Dxing
And a stationary HAM radio can only be used in one location.
And can relay messages locally from roving ops checking on health and
welfare, as well Statewide, Country wide, and World wide. Don't
forget that hams work in coordination with each other, some mobile,
and someone at the base with a tower relaying the information locally
or statewide as necessary.
Post by SC Dxing
Not very good, if you are going around house to house checking on people in an
emergency.
But ham radio can be used both portable and base, a repeater statioin
also comes to mind as a coordinated effort that has proven itself time
and time again.
Post by SC Dxing
A stationary tower is probably the worst choice for
emergency communications.
Why. Every emergeny service in the US uses stationary stations with
towers as the hub to their operations.
Post by SC Dxing
Satellite phone. Never ever goes out as long as you got it charged.
Never.
Most folks are not going to pay the outlandish monthly fees for a
satellite phone + air time. The only reason your sat phone works is
because not many folks have them. Just imagine if everyone had a sat
phone instead of a cell phone. I can tell you from experience that on
September 11, the whole cell phone infrastructure crashed and was not
operable.
If everyone had sat phones, it would overload the capablility of the
sat, and your phone would be worthless.
Post by SC Dxing
Post by RHF
sounds more like a towering monument to
someone's personal status and ego ~ RHF
.
Agreed. There was a time when a HAM radio operator was a real asset in
a disaster. But with the advances in technology, especially portable
communications, those days have passed.
So where were all of the so called advances when Katrina took out the
Gulf Coast? Or during the recent ice storms up North. Hams have
activiely assisted on both events and every major emergency in
between.
BTW, Which emergency organization does your wife work for, I would
like to find out why they are not adhering to the policies set forth
in the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) 2007 Appropriations Act
(HR 5441). Which indicates that Amateur Radio should be incorperated
into the contingent plans by all communities for emergency and
disaster prepardness.
DL
You may be able to help a few or many -but-What
about the hundreds of 'others' in need of H-E-L-P too ?
But the Average Citizen is NOT prepared : That Has
Got To Change : Putting a FRS, GMRS, and/or CB
Radio in the Hands of American Household can make
it possible to HELP Hundreds of People in Need.
But RHF, why try to reinvent the wheel?  The Amateur Radio Service is
alreday recognized by most emergency organizations as the go to folks
when they need additionally capacity to handle communication duties.
Putting hundreds of thousands of FRS, GMRS, and CB's into the hands
every citizen will cause nothing but jammed frequencies and an
overloaded of panicked citizens all crying out for help at the same
time. Imagine 25,000 cb radios or FRS radios all transmitting at once
crying out for help....What you would have is nothing but a garbled
mess.
The first rule of emergency comms is to have a well defined plan that
consists of already trained folks who know how to use the equipment
they have, and are trained to prioritize the comms in a useful
manner.  In reality, if folks feel that strong about it having the
capability, a ham ticket is easily obtained, and there are hams whoes
only interest in ham radio is emergency comms, training for it, and
support thereof.
Post by RHF
Every Citizen a Neighbor and Neightbors Helping
Neighbors in their Local Neighborhoods. ~ RHF
And how are they going to help, who is going to be able to handle the
"all at once" radio traffic that would barrage the EC under your
scenario.  Even at the local level, such at a fire station, there
would not be enough staff to handle the traffic. Imagine 5000 calls
coming in at one time.
DL
DL,

CHOICE : Using the 'few' Technical Experts
-or- Empowering Each and Every US Citizen
To Help Themselves and Each Other in a
Local Emergency : Using the best of Today's
Communication Technology including :
1 - Radio and TV {Internet}
* Emergency AM/FM Radio Crank-Up & Battery
2 - Cellphones and Telephones
3 - FRS + GMRS + CB Radios
4 - If All Else Fails Amateur Radio Operators

Sort of Like the Individual Citizens Right to . . .
Talkie-Talkie {2-Way Radio}
-aka- Right To Bear Arms {Be Prepared}
[Citizen's Self-Defense in a Natural Emergency]
+ 3-Days Safe Water Supply
+ 3-Days Canned Food
+ Emergency First Aid & Survival Kits
http://www.campingsurvival.com/suremkit.html
http://www.campingsurvival.com/suremkit.html
+ Emergency Signal Whistle / Safety Horn
http://www.safetycentral.com/stormwhistle.html
http://www.safetycentral.com/masaplblho.html
+ Emergency AM/FM Radio Crank-Up & Battery
+ Emergency LED Lights Crank-Up & Battery
+ Emergency FRS + GMRS + CB Radios
+ Rain & Cold Weather Gear
+ Extra Blankets

Here are a few Bright Ideas :
* Coleman Storm Beam Dynamo Lantern
http://www.mcsports.com/product/index.jsp?productId=3030061
* Coleman PerfectFlow Two-Mantle Propane Lantern
http://www.safetycentral.com/copetwprla.html
* Kerosene Hurricane Lantern, 7.5" - 6 Candle Power
http://www.safetycentral.com/hurlan50ser.html
* ACE Camping Lantern
http://www.acehardware.com/product/index.jsp?productId=1787728

i am not anti-hams - just 'pro' active citizenry ~ RHF
.
d***@hotmail.com
2009-01-13 21:56:34 UTC
Permalink
Post by RHF
Post by RHF
Post by d***@hotmail.com
Post by SC Dxing
A hurricane/snow storm can easily take out any antenna tower.
So me evidence to back up your claims. I've had multiple towers in
many locations and I've never lost one to a snow storm, ice storm,
hurricane, or tornado. Usually, the tower is the one thing that
survives.
Post by SC Dxing
Then you need electricity
Generators are fairly plentiful and run for days on 200 gallons of
propane.
Post by SC Dxing
Then you need someone who is going to listen on the
other side.
And hams do listen 24/7, somewhere in the world someone is always
listening. During Katrina, thounsands of traffic messages were passed,
as has many messages been handled during a lot of the ice storms this
season up North.
Post by SC Dxing
My wife works for emergency services and not a single
emergency scenario involves using ham radio operators.
Then they are not utilizing all the resources available to them.
Thankfully, my community involves all legitimate parties during every
emergency exercise, including ham radio ops, but CB radio and FRS are
never included because the folks who own FRS want to have a family CB
service, and CB radio ops are too busy trying to play who has the
biggest illegal amplfier. The users of CB and FRS do not have an
interest in emergency coms until something happens, then they show up
untrained, uncoordinated, and become an hinderance to any on going
operations.
Post by SC Dxing
If anything, CB radio or mobile UHF/VHF device would be more reliable.
Hams use UHF and VHF, so your point is??? And mobile CB is useless
more than 5-10 miles away unless you are running illegal power.
Post by SC Dxing
And a stationary HAM radio can only be used in one location.
And can relay messages locally from roving ops checking on health and
welfare, as well Statewide, Country wide, and World wide. Don't
forget that hams work in coordination with each other, some mobile,
and someone at the base with a tower relaying the information locally
or statewide as necessary.
Post by SC Dxing
Not very good, if you are going around house to house checking on people in an
emergency.
But ham radio can be used both portable and base, a repeater statioin
also comes to mind as a coordinated effort that has proven itself time
and time again.
Post by SC Dxing
A stationary tower is probably the worst choice for
emergency communications.
Why. Every emergeny service in the US uses stationary stations with
towers as the hub to their operations.
Post by SC Dxing
Satellite phone. Never ever goes out as long as you got it charged.
Never.
Most folks are not going to pay the outlandish monthly fees for a
satellite phone + air time. The only reason your sat phone works is
because not many folks have them. Just imagine if everyone had a sat
phone instead of a cell phone. I can tell you from experience that on
September 11, the whole cell phone infrastructure crashed and was not
operable.
If everyone had sat phones, it would overload the capablility of the
sat, and your phone would be worthless.
Post by SC Dxing
Post by RHF
sounds more like a towering monument to
someone's personal status and ego ~ RHF
.
Agreed. There was a time when a HAM radio operator was a real asset in
a disaster. But with the advances in technology, especially portable
communications, those days have passed.
So where were all of the so called advances when Katrina took out the
Gulf Coast? Or during the recent ice storms up North. Hams have
activiely assisted on both events and every major emergency in
between.
BTW, Which emergency organization does your wife work for, I would
like to find out why they are not adhering to the policies set forth
in the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) 2007 Appropriations Act
(HR 5441). Which indicates that Amateur Radio should be incorperated
into the contingent plans by all communities for emergency and
disaster prepardness.
DL
You may be able to help a few or many -but-What
about the hundreds of 'others' in need of H-E-L-P too ?
But the Average Citizen is NOT prepared : That Has
Got To Change : Putting a FRS, GMRS, and/or CB
Radio in the Hands of American Household can make
it possible to HELP Hundreds of People in Need.
But RHF, why try to reinvent the wheel? �The Amateur Radio Service is
alreday recognized by most emergency organizations as the go to folks
when they need additionally capacity to handle communication duties.
Putting hundreds of thousands of FRS, GMRS, and CB's into the hands
every citizen will cause nothing but jammed frequencies and an
overloaded of panicked citizens all crying out for help at the same
time. Imagine 25,000 cb radios or FRS radios all transmitting at once
crying out for help....What you would have is nothing but a garbled
mess.
The first rule of emergency comms is to have a well defined plan that
consists of already trained folks who know how to use the equipment
they have, and are trained to prioritize the comms in a useful
manner. �In reality, if folks feel that strong about it having the
capability, a ham ticket is easily obtained, and there are hams whoes
only interest in ham radio is emergency comms, training for it, and
support thereof.
Post by RHF
Every Citizen a Neighbor and Neightbors Helping
Neighbors in their Local Neighborhoods. ~ RHF
And how are they going to help, who is going to be able to handle the
"all at once" radio traffic that would barrage the EC under your
scenario. �Even at the local level, such at a fire station, there
would not be enough staff to handle the traffic. Imagine 5000 calls
coming in at one time.
DL
DL,
CHOICE : Using the 'few' Technical Experts
-or- Empowering Each and Every US Citizen
To Help Themselves and Each Other in a
Local Emergency : Using the best of Today's
1 - Radio and TV {Internet}
* Emergency AM/FM Radio Crank-Up & Battery
2 - Cellphones and Telephones
3 - FRS + GMRS + CB Radios
4 - If All Else Fails Amateur Radio Operators
Sort of Like the Individual Citizens Right to . . .
Talkie-Talkie {2-Way Radio}
-aka- Right To Bear Arms {Be Prepared}
[Citizen's Self-Defense in a Natural Emergency]
+ 3-Days Safe Water Supply
+ 3-Days Canned Food
+ Emergency First Aid & Survival Kitshttp://www.campingsurvival.com/suremkit.htmlhttp://www.campingsurvival.com/suremkit.html
+ Emergency Signal Whistle / Safety Hornhttp://www.safetycentral.com/stormwhistle.htmlhttp://www.safetycentral.com/masaplblho.html
+ Emergency AM/FM Radio Crank-Up & Battery
+ Emergency LED Lights Crank-Up & Battery
+ Emergency FRS + GMRS + CB Radios
+ Rain & Cold Weather Gear
+ Extra Blankets
* Coleman Storm Beam Dynamo Lanternhttp://www.mcsports.com/product/index.jsp?productId=3030061
* Coleman PerfectFlow Two-Mantle Propane Lanternhttp://www.safetycentral.com/copetwprla.html
* Kerosene Hurricane Lantern, 7.5" - 6 Candle Powerhttp://www.safetycentral.com/hurlan50ser.html
* ACE Camping Lanternhttp://www.acehardware.com/product/index.jsp?productId=1787728
i am not anti-hams - just 'pro' active citizenry ~ RHF
RHF, I am also pro-active citizenry. I certainly can agree that any
type of communication device which will allow you to communicate to
someone during an emergency is better than nothing at all.

However as you pointed out, I am thinking like a ham, I can't help but
at least try to plant a seed to increase the pool of ham radio
operators who could be used during emergencies. Imagine if all
citizens were licensed (such as being part of the science ciriculum at
the elementary level), been trained to handle emergencies, and made
themselves available for at least one 12 hour shift during an
emergency. What a wonderful concept, unrealistic I agree, but still
it would really show some good community sprit.

Nice topic and thread...73

DL
RHF
2009-01-13 23:34:19 UTC
Permalink
Post by d***@hotmail.com
Post by RHF
Post by RHF
Post by d***@hotmail.com
Post by SC Dxing
A hurricane/snow storm can easily take out any antenna tower.
So me evidence to back up your claims. I've had multiple towers in
many locations and I've never lost one to a snow storm, ice storm,
hurricane, or tornado. Usually, the tower is the one thing that
survives.
Post by SC Dxing
Then you need electricity
Generators are fairly plentiful and run for days on 200 gallons of
propane.
Post by SC Dxing
Then you need someone who is going to listen on the
other side.
And hams do listen 24/7, somewhere in the world someone is always
listening. During Katrina, thounsands of traffic messages were passed,
as has many messages been handled during a lot of the ice storms this
season up North.
Post by SC Dxing
My wife works for emergency services and not a single
emergency scenario involves using ham radio operators.
Then they are not utilizing all the resources available to them.
Thankfully, my community involves all legitimate parties during every
emergency exercise, including ham radio ops, but CB radio and FRS are
never included because the folks who own FRS want to have a family CB
service, and CB radio ops are too busy trying to play who has the
biggest illegal amplfier. The users of CB and FRS do not have an
interest in emergency coms until something happens, then they show up
untrained, uncoordinated, and become an hinderance to any on going
operations.
Post by SC Dxing
If anything, CB radio or mobile UHF/VHF device would be more reliable.
Hams use UHF and VHF, so your point is??? And mobile CB is useless
more than 5-10 miles away unless you are running illegal power.
Post by SC Dxing
And a stationary HAM radio can only be used in one location.
And can relay messages locally from roving ops checking on health and
welfare, as well Statewide, Country wide, and World wide. Don't
forget that hams work in coordination with each other, some mobile,
and someone at the base with a tower relaying the information locally
or statewide as necessary.
Post by SC Dxing
Not very good, if you are going around house to house checking on people in an
emergency.
But ham radio can be used both portable and base, a repeater statioin
also comes to mind as a coordinated effort that has proven itself time
and time again.
Post by SC Dxing
A stationary tower is probably the worst choice for
emergency communications.
Why. Every emergeny service in the US uses stationary stations with
towers as the hub to their operations.
Post by SC Dxing
Satellite phone. Never ever goes out as long as you got it charged.
Never.
Most folks are not going to pay the outlandish monthly fees for a
satellite phone + air time. The only reason your sat phone works is
because not many folks have them. Just imagine if everyone had a sat
phone instead of a cell phone. I can tell you from experience that on
September 11, the whole cell phone infrastructure crashed and was not
operable.
If everyone had sat phones, it would overload the capablility of the
sat, and your phone would be worthless.
Post by SC Dxing
Post by RHF
sounds more like a towering monument to
someone's personal status and ego ~ RHF
.
Agreed. There was a time when a HAM radio operator was a real asset in
a disaster. But with the advances in technology, especially portable
communications, those days have passed.
So where were all of the so called advances when Katrina took out the
Gulf Coast? Or during the recent ice storms up North. Hams have
activiely assisted on both events and every major emergency in
between.
BTW, Which emergency organization does your wife work for, I would
like to find out why they are not adhering to the policies set forth
in the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) 2007 Appropriations Act
(HR 5441). Which indicates that Amateur Radio should be incorperated
into the contingent plans by all communities for emergency and
disaster prepardness.
DL
You may be able to help a few or many -but-What
about the hundreds of 'others' in need of H-E-L-P too ?
But the Average Citizen is NOT prepared : That Has
Got To Change : Putting a FRS, GMRS, and/or CB
Radio in the Hands of American Household can make
it possible to HELP Hundreds of People in Need.
But RHF, why try to reinvent the wheel? The Amateur Radio Service is
alreday recognized by most emergency organizations as the go to folks
when they need additionally capacity to handle communication duties.
Putting hundreds of thousands of FRS, GMRS, and CB's into the hands
every citizen will cause nothing but jammed frequencies and an
overloaded of panicked citizens all crying out for help at the same
time. Imagine 25,000 cb radios or FRS radios all transmitting at once
crying out for help....What you would have is nothing but a garbled
mess.
The first rule of emergency comms is to have a well defined plan that
consists of already trained folks who know how to use the equipment
they have, and are trained to prioritize the comms in a useful
manner. In reality, if folks feel that strong about it having the
capability, a ham ticket is easily obtained, and there are hams whoes
only interest in ham radio is emergency comms, training for it, and
support thereof.
Post by RHF
Every Citizen a Neighbor and Neightbors Helping
Neighbors in their Local Neighborhoods. ~ RHF
And how are they going to help, who is going to be able to handle the
"all at once" radio traffic that would barrage the EC under your
scenario. Even at the local level, such at a fire station, there
would not be enough staff to handle the traffic. Imagine 5000 calls
coming in at one time.
DL
DL,
CHOICE : Using the 'few' Technical Experts
-or- Empowering Each and Every US Citizen
To Help Themselves and Each Other in a
Local Emergency : Using the best of Today's
1 - Radio and TV {Internet}
* Emergency AM/FM Radio Crank-Up & Battery
2 - Cellphones and Telephones
3 - FRS + GMRS + CB Radios
4 - If All Else Fails Amateur Radio Operators
Sort of Like the Individual Citizens Right to . . .
Talkie-Talkie {2-Way Radio}
-aka- Right To Bear Arms {Be Prepared}
[Citizen's Self-Defense in a Natural Emergency]
+ 3-Days Safe Water Supply
+ 3-Days Canned Food
+ Emergency First Aid & Survival Kitshttp://www.campingsurvival.com/suremkit.htmlhttp://www.campingsurviva...
+ Emergency Signal Whistle / Safety Hornhttp://www.safetycentral.com/stormwhistle.htmlhttp://www.safetycentra...
+ Emergency AM/FM Radio Crank-Up & Battery
+ Emergency LED Lights Crank-Up & Battery
+ Emergency FRS + GMRS + CB Radios
+ Rain & Cold Weather Gear
+ Extra Blankets
* Coleman Storm Beam Dynamo Lanternhttp://www.mcsports.com/product/index.jsp?productId=3030061
* Coleman PerfectFlow Two-Mantle Propane Lanternhttp://www.safetycentral.com/copetwprla.html
* Kerosene Hurricane Lantern, 7.5" - 6 Candle Powerhttp://www.safetycentral.com/hurlan50ser.html
* ACE Camping Lanternhttp://www.acehardware.com/product/index.jsp?productId=1787728
i am not anti-hams - just 'pro' active citizenry ~ RHF
RHF, I am also pro-active citizenry. I certainly can agree that any
type of communication device which will allow you to communicate to
someone during an emergency is better than nothing at all.
However as you pointed out, I am thinking like a ham, I can't help but
at least try to plant a seed to increase the pool of ham radio
operators who could be used during emergencies.  Imagine if all
citizens were licensed (such as being part of the science ciriculum at
the elementary level), been trained to handle emergencies, and made
themselves available for at least one 12 hour shift during an
emergency.  What a wonderful concept, unrealistic I agree, but still
it would really show some good community sprit.
Nice topic and thread...73
DL
DL - Think Long Term :

Question : What Today would be the Natural
Avenue for someone to Learn-Up to becoming
an Amateur {Ham} Radio Operator ?

Every Amateur Radio Club should offer a Class
in Emergency Communications for Citizens with
FRS, GMRS and CB Radios :
* What To Do in an Emergency
* Getting Prepared for a Local Emergency
* How To Use Your 2-Way Radios
* Going The Extra Step : How You Can Help Others
* What More . . . Become a Ham

idtars ~ RHF
.
d***@hotmail.com
2009-01-14 00:53:55 UTC
Permalink
Post by RHF
Post by d***@hotmail.com
Post by RHF
Post by RHF
Post by d***@hotmail.com
Post by SC Dxing
A hurricane/snow storm can easily take out any antenna tower.
So me evidence to back up your claims. I've had multiple towers in
many locations and I've never lost one to a snow storm, ice storm,
hurricane, or tornado. Usually, the tower is the one thing that
survives.
Post by SC Dxing
Then you need electricity
Generators are fairly plentiful and run for days on 200 gallons of
propane.
Post by SC Dxing
Then you need someone who is going to listen on the
other side.
And hams do listen 24/7, somewhere in the world someone is always
listening. During Katrina, thounsands of traffic messages were passed,
as has many messages been handled during a lot of the ice storms this
season up North.
Post by SC Dxing
My wife works for emergency services and not a single
emergency scenario involves using ham radio operators.
Then they are not utilizing all the resources available to them.
Thankfully, my community involves all legitimate parties during every
emergency exercise, including ham radio ops, but CB radio and FRS are
never included because the folks who own FRS want to have a family CB
service, and CB radio ops are too busy trying to play who has the
biggest illegal amplfier. The users of CB and FRS do not have an
interest in emergency coms until something happens, then they show up
untrained, uncoordinated, and become an hinderance to any on going
operations.
Post by SC Dxing
If anything, CB radio or mobile UHF/VHF device would be more reliable.
Hams use UHF and VHF, so your point is??? And mobile CB is useless
more than 5-10 miles away unless you are running illegal power.
Post by SC Dxing
And a stationary HAM radio can only be used in one location.
And can relay messages locally from roving ops checking on health and
welfare, as well Statewide, Country wide, and World wide. Don't
forget that hams work in coordination with each other, some mobile,
and someone at the base with a tower relaying the information locally
or statewide as necessary.
Post by SC Dxing
Not very good, if you are going around house to house checking on people in an
emergency.
But ham radio can be used both portable and base, a repeater statioin
also comes to mind as a coordinated effort that has proven itself time
and time again.
Post by SC Dxing
A stationary tower is probably the worst choice for
emergency communications.
Why. Every emergeny service in the US uses stationary stations with
towers as the hub to their operations.
Post by SC Dxing
Satellite phone. Never ever goes out as long as you got it charged.
Never.
Most folks are not going to pay the outlandish monthly fees for a
satellite phone + air time. The only reason your sat phone works is
because not many folks have them. Just imagine if everyone had a sat
phone instead of a cell phone. I can tell you from experience that on
September 11, the whole cell phone infrastructure crashed and was not
operable.
If everyone had sat phones, it would overload the capablility of the
sat, and your phone would be worthless.
Post by SC Dxing
Post by RHF
sounds more like a towering monument to
someone's personal status and ego ~ RHF
.
Agreed. There was a time when a HAM radio operator was a real asset in
a disaster. But with the advances in technology, especially portable
communications, those days have passed.
So where were all of the so called advances when Katrina took out the
Gulf Coast? Or during the recent ice storms up North. Hams have
activiely assisted on both events and every major emergency in
between.
BTW, Which emergency organization does your wife work for, I would
like to find out why they are not adhering to the policies set forth
in the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) 2007 Appropriations Act
(HR 5441). Which indicates that Amateur Radio should be incorperated
into the contingent plans by all communities for emergency and
disaster prepardness.
DL
You may be able to help a few or many -but-What
about the hundreds of 'others' in need of H-E-L-P too ?
But the Average Citizen is NOT prepared : That Has
Got To Change : Putting a FRS, GMRS, and/or CB
Radio in the Hands of American Household can make
it possible to HELP Hundreds of People in Need.
But RHF, why try to reinvent the wheel? The Amateur Radio Service is
alreday recognized by most emergency organizations as the go to folks
when they need additionally capacity to handle communication duties.
Putting hundreds of thousands of FRS, GMRS, and CB's into the hands
every citizen will cause nothing but jammed frequencies and an
overloaded of panicked citizens all crying out for help at the same
time. Imagine 25,000 cb radios or FRS radios all transmitting at once
crying out for help....What you would have is nothing but a garbled
mess.
The first rule of emergency comms is to have a well defined plan that
consists of already trained folks who know how to use the equipment
they have, and are trained to prioritize the comms in a useful
manner. In reality, if folks feel that strong about it having the
capability, a ham ticket is easily obtained, and there are hams whoes
only interest in ham radio is emergency comms, training for it, and
support thereof.
Post by RHF
Every Citizen a Neighbor and Neightbors Helping
Neighbors in their Local Neighborhoods. ~ RHF
And how are they going to help, who is going to be able to handle the
"all at once" radio traffic that would barrage the EC under your
scenario. Even at the local level, such at a fire station, there
would not be enough staff to handle the traffic. Imagine 5000 calls
coming in at one time.
DL
DL,
CHOICE : Using the 'few' Technical Experts
-or- Empowering Each and Every US Citizen
To Help Themselves and Each Other in a
Local Emergency : Using the best of Today's
1 - Radio and TV {Internet}
* Emergency AM/FM Radio Crank-Up & Battery
2 - Cellphones and Telephones
3 - FRS + GMRS + CB Radios
4 - If All Else Fails Amateur Radio Operators
Sort of Like the Individual Citizens Right to . . .
Talkie-Talkie {2-Way Radio}
-aka- Right To Bear Arms {Be Prepared}
[Citizen's Self-Defense in a Natural Emergency]
+ 3-Days Safe Water Supply
+ 3-Days Canned Food
+ Emergency First Aid & Survival Kitshttp://www.campingsurvival.com/suremkit.htmlhttp://www.campingsurviva...
+ Emergency Signal Whistle / Safety Hornhttp://www.safetycentral.com/stormwhistle.htmlhttp://www.safetycentra...
+ Emergency AM/FM Radio Crank-Up & Battery
+ Emergency LED Lights Crank-Up & Battery
+ Emergency FRS + GMRS + CB Radios
+ Rain & Cold Weather Gear
+ Extra Blankets
* Coleman Storm Beam Dynamo Lanternhttp://www.mcsports.com/product/index.jsp?productId=3030061
* Coleman PerfectFlow Two-Mantle Propane Lanternhttp://www.safetycentral.com/copetwprla.html
* Kerosene Hurricane Lantern, 7.5" - 6 Candle Powerhttp://www.safetycentral.com/hurlan50ser.html
* ACE Camping Lanternhttp://www.acehardware.com/product/index.jsp?productId=1787728
i am not anti-hams - just 'pro' active citizenry ~ RHF
RHF, I am also pro-active citizenry. I certainly can agree that any
type of communication device which will allow you to communicate to
someone during an emergency is better than nothing at all.
However as you pointed out, I am thinking like a ham, I can't help but
at least try to plant a seed to increase the pool of ham radio
operators who could be used during emergencies. �Imagine if all
citizens were licensed (such as being part of the science ciriculum at
the elementary level), been trained to handle emergencies, and made
themselves available for at least one 12 hour shift during an
emergency. �What a wonderful concept, unrealistic I agree, but still
it would really show some good community sprit.
Nice topic and thread...73
DL
Question : What Today would be the Natural
Avenue for someone to Learn-Up to becoming
an Amateur {Ham} Radio Operator ?
The easiest avenue of course these days would be to use the internet
to find where and when testing is given, and then choose your avenue
of study, i.e. self study using study aides that are available free on
the internet, use a book obtained through purchase or the library,
such as a current ARRL license study guide, elmering with a local ham,
or take a class given by a local club. Of course this brings up
another of what I perceive has always been a problem with the ARS, and
that is the lack of exposure. Honestly, before I became a ham, I had
never heard of ham radio until someone I met through a mutual friend
was a ham. Most citizens, it seems, do not even know the Amateur
Radio Service exists, or the wide diversity within the hobby from
DXing, to the digital modes, slow scan TV, experimentation, and
emergency communication support. We are mostly viewed as a "odd bunch
with all those antennas".

Nevertheless, it seems that a significant portion of growth of the ARS
is derived from other interest groups such as scouting, clubs,
emergency first responders, and the National Weather Service with its
Skywarn program. Having an affiliation with one of those groups can
also provide a path to obtaining a license.

A ham license these days is easier than ever to obtain, with the
elimination of the morse code requirement, there are kids as young as
10 years of age who have earned the highest class license. A good
starting point is here. http://www.emergency-radio.org/
Post by RHF
Every Amateur Radio Club should offer a Class
in Emergency Communications for Citizens with
* What To Do in an Emergency
* Getting Prepared for a Local Emergency
* How To Use Your 2-Way Radios
* Going The Extra Step : How You Can Help Others
* What More . . . Become a Ham
There actually are a lot of clubs who offer emergency courses for
anyone with an interest, and the American Red Cross also offers these
courses from time to time. The ARRL also offers a series of online
courses for those who have an interest in emergency communications.
This one is a good atarting point. http://www.arrl.org/cce/courses.html#EC-001
Post by RHF
idtars ~ RHF
73 DL
RHF
2009-01-15 06:23:07 UTC
Permalink
Post by d***@hotmail.com
Post by RHF
Post by d***@hotmail.com
Post by RHF
Post by RHF
Post by d***@hotmail.com
Post by SC Dxing
A hurricane/snow storm can easily take out any antenna tower.
So me evidence to back up your claims. I've had multiple towers in
many locations and I've never lost one to a snow storm, ice storm,
hurricane, or tornado. Usually, the tower is the one thing that
survives.
Post by SC Dxing
Then you need electricity
Generators are fairly plentiful and run for days on 200 gallons of
propane.
Post by SC Dxing
Then you need someone who is going to listen on the
other side.
And hams do listen 24/7, somewhere in the world someone is always
listening. During Katrina, thounsands of traffic messages were passed,
as has many messages been handled during a lot of the ice storms this
season up North.
Post by SC Dxing
My wife works for emergency services and not a single
emergency scenario involves using ham radio operators.
Then they are not utilizing all the resources available to them.
Thankfully, my community involves all legitimate parties during every
emergency exercise, including ham radio ops, but CB radio and FRS are
never included because the folks who own FRS want to have a family CB
service, and CB radio ops are too busy trying to play who has the
biggest illegal amplfier. The users of CB and FRS do not have an
interest in emergency coms until something happens, then they show up
untrained, uncoordinated, and become an hinderance to any on going
operations.
Post by SC Dxing
If anything, CB radio or mobile UHF/VHF device would be more reliable.
Hams use UHF and VHF, so your point is??? And mobile CB is useless
more than 5-10 miles away unless you are running illegal power.
Post by SC Dxing
And a stationary HAM radio can only be used in one location.
And can relay messages locally from roving ops checking on health and
welfare, as well Statewide, Country wide, and World wide. Don't
forget that hams work in coordination with each other, some mobile,
and someone at the base with a tower relaying the information locally
or statewide as necessary.
Post by SC Dxing
Not very good, if you are going around house to house checking on people in an
emergency.
But ham radio can be used both portable and base, a repeater statioin
also comes to mind as a coordinated effort that has proven itself time
and time again.
Post by SC Dxing
A stationary tower is probably the worst choice for
emergency communications.
Why. Every emergeny service in the US uses stationary stations with
towers as the hub to their operations.
Post by SC Dxing
Satellite phone. Never ever goes out as long as you got it charged.
Never.
Most folks are not going to pay the outlandish monthly fees for a
satellite phone + air time. The only reason your sat phone works is
because not many folks have them. Just imagine if everyone had a sat
phone instead of a cell phone. I can tell you from experience that on
September 11, the whole cell phone infrastructure crashed and was not
operable.
If everyone had sat phones, it would overload the capablility of the
sat, and your phone would be worthless.
Post by SC Dxing
Post by RHF
sounds more like a towering monument to
someone's personal status and ego ~ RHF
.
Agreed. There was a time when a HAM radio operator was a real asset in
a disaster. But with the advances in technology, especially portable
communications, those days have passed.
So where were all of the so called advances when Katrina took out the
Gulf Coast? Or during the recent ice storms up North. Hams have
activiely assisted on both events and every major emergency in
between.
BTW, Which emergency organization does your wife work for, I would
like to find out why they are not adhering to the policies set forth
in the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) 2007 Appropriations Act
(HR 5441). Which indicates that Amateur Radio should be incorperated
into the contingent plans by all communities for emergency and
disaster prepardness.
DL
You may be able to help a few or many -but-What
about the hundreds of 'others' in need of H-E-L-P too ?
But the Average Citizen is NOT prepared : That Has
Got To Change : Putting a FRS, GMRS, and/or CB
Radio in the Hands of American Household can make
it possible to HELP Hundreds of People in Need.
But RHF, why try to reinvent the wheel? The Amateur Radio Service is
alreday recognized by most emergency organizations as the go to folks
when they need additionally capacity to handle communication duties.
Putting hundreds of thousands of FRS, GMRS, and CB's into the hands
every citizen will cause nothing but jammed frequencies and an
overloaded of panicked citizens all crying out for help at the same
time. Imagine 25,000 cb radios or FRS radios all transmitting at once
crying out for help....What you would have is nothing but a garbled
mess.
The first rule of emergency comms is to have a well defined plan that
consists of already trained folks who know how to use the equipment
they have, and are trained to prioritize the comms in a useful
manner. In reality, if folks feel that strong about it having the
capability, a ham ticket is easily obtained, and there are hams whoes
only interest in ham radio is emergency comms, training for it, and
support thereof.
Post by RHF
Every Citizen a Neighbor and Neightbors Helping
Neighbors in their Local Neighborhoods. ~ RHF
And how are they going to help, who is going to be able to handle the
"all at once" radio traffic that would barrage the EC under your
scenario. Even at the local level, such at a fire station, there
would not be enough staff to handle the traffic. Imagine 5000 calls
coming in at one time.
DL
DL,
CHOICE : Using the 'few' Technical Experts
-or- Empowering Each and Every US Citizen
To Help Themselves and Each Other in a
Local Emergency : Using the best of Today's
1 - Radio and TV {Internet}
* Emergency AM/FM Radio Crank-Up & Battery
2 - Cellphones and Telephones
3 - FRS + GMRS + CB Radios
4 - If All Else Fails Amateur Radio Operators
Sort of Like the Individual Citizens Right to . . .
Talkie-Talkie {2-Way Radio}
-aka- Right To Bear Arms {Be Prepared}
[Citizen's Self-Defense in a Natural Emergency]
+ 3-Days Safe Water Supply
+ 3-Days Canned Food
+ Emergency First Aid & Survival Kitshttp://www.campingsurvival.com/suremkit.htmlhttp://www.campingsurviva...
+ Emergency Signal Whistle / Safety Hornhttp://www.safetycentral.com/stormwhistle.htmlhttp://www.safetycentra...
+ Emergency AM/FM Radio Crank-Up & Battery
+ Emergency LED Lights Crank-Up & Battery
+ Emergency FRS + GMRS + CB Radios
+ Rain & Cold Weather Gear
+ Extra Blankets
* Coleman Storm Beam Dynamo Lanternhttp://www.mcsports.com/product/index.jsp?productId=3030061
* Coleman PerfectFlow Two-Mantle Propane Lanternhttp://www.safetycentral.com/copetwprla.html
* Kerosene Hurricane Lantern, 7.5" - 6 Candle Powerhttp://www.safetycentral.com/hurlan50ser.html
* ACE Camping Lanternhttp://www.acehardware.com/product/index.jsp?productId=1787728
i am not anti-hams - just 'pro' active citizenry ~ RHF
RHF, I am also pro-active citizenry. I certainly can agree that any
type of communication device which will allow you to communicate to
someone during an emergency is better than nothing at all.
However as you pointed out, I am thinking like a ham, I can't help but
at least try to plant a seed to increase the pool of ham radio
operators who could be used during emergencies. Imagine if all
citizens were licensed (such as being part of the science ciriculum at
the elementary level), been trained to handle emergencies, and made
themselves available for at least one 12 hour shift during an
emergency. What a wonderful concept, unrealistic I agree, but still
it would really show some good community sprit.
Nice topic and thread...73
DL
Question : What Today would be the Natural
Avenue for someone to Learn-Up to becoming
an Amateur {Ham} Radio Operator ?
The easiest avenue of course these days would be to use the internet
to find where and when testing is given, and then choose your avenue
of study, i.e. self study using study aides that are available free on
the internet, use a book obtained through purchase or the library,
such ...
read more »
DL,

There has to be that "First Experience" {Excitement}
with a 2-Way Radio in your Hand : To Get You To
Take the Next-Step and Want More . . .

The Internet is too-easy and seductive and will
simply make you a Keyboard and iChat Junkie.

The 'Future' of HAM Radio is built-on the foundation
or 'other' 2-Way Radio Service Users ~ RHF
.
an_old_friend
2009-01-14 23:21:26 UTC
Permalink
Post by RHF
Post by d***@hotmail.com
Post by RHF
Post by RHF
Post by d***@hotmail.com
Post by SC Dxing
A hurricane/snow storm can easily take out any antenna tower.
So me evidence to back up your claims. I've had multiple towers in
many locations and I've never lost one to a snow storm, ice storm,
hurricane, or tornado. Usually, the tower is the one thing that
survives.
Post by SC Dxing
Then you need electricity
Generators are fairly plentiful and run for days on 200 gallons of
propane.
Post by SC Dxing
Then you need someone who is going to listen on the
other side.
And hams do listen 24/7, somewhere in the world someone is always
listening. During Katrina, thounsands of traffic messages were passed,
as has many messages been handled during a lot of the ice storms this
season up North.
Post by SC Dxing
My wife works for emergency services and not a single
emergency scenario involves using ham radio operators.
Then they are not utilizing all the resources available to them.
Thankfully, my community involves all legitimate parties during every
emergency exercise, including ham radio ops, but CB radio and FRS are
never included because the folks who own FRS want to have a family CB
service, and CB radio ops are too busy trying to play who has the
biggest illegal amplfier. The users of CB and FRS do not have an
interest in emergency coms until something happens, then they show up
untrained, uncoordinated, and become an hinderance to any on going
operations.
Post by SC Dxing
If anything, CB radio or mobile UHF/VHF device would be more reliable.
Hams use UHF and VHF, so your point is??? And mobile CB is useless
more than 5-10 miles away unless you are running illegal power.
Post by SC Dxing
And a stationary HAM radio can only be used in one location.
And can relay messages locally from roving ops checking on health and
welfare, as well Statewide, Country wide, and World wide. Don't
forget that hams work in coordination with each other, some mobile,
and someone at the base with a tower relaying the information locally
or statewide as necessary.
Post by SC Dxing
Not very good, if you are going around house to house checking on people in an
emergency.
But ham radio can be used both portable and base, a repeater statioin
also comes to mind as a coordinated effort that has proven itself time
and time again.
Post by SC Dxing
A stationary tower is probably the worst choice for
emergency communications.
Why. Every emergeny service in the US uses stationary stations with
towers as the hub to their operations.
Post by SC Dxing
Satellite phone. Never ever goes out as long as you got it charged.
Never.
Most folks are not going to pay the outlandish monthly fees for a
satellite phone + air time. The only reason your sat phone works is
because not many folks have them. Just imagine if everyone had a sat
phone instead of a cell phone. I can tell you from experience that on
September 11, the whole cell phone infrastructure crashed and was not
operable.
If everyone had sat phones, it would overload the capablility of the
sat, and your phone would be worthless.
Post by SC Dxing
Post by RHF
sounds more like a towering monument to
someone's personal status and ego ~ RHF
.
Agreed. There was a time when a HAM radio operator was a real asset in
a disaster. But with the advances in technology, especially portable
communications, those days have passed.
So where were all of the so called advances when Katrina took out the
Gulf Coast? Or during the recent ice storms up North. Hams have
activiely assisted on both events and every major emergency in
between.
BTW, Which emergency organization does your wife work for, I would
like to find out why they are not adhering to the policies set forth
in the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) 2007 Appropriations Act
(HR 5441). Which indicates that Amateur Radio should be incorperated
into the contingent plans by all communities for emergency and
disaster prepardness.
DL
You may be able to help a few or many -but-What
about the hundreds of 'others' in need of H-E-L-P too ?
But the Average Citizen is NOT prepared : That Has
Got To Change : Putting a FRS, GMRS, and/or CB
Radio in the Hands of American Household can make
it possible to HELP Hundreds of People in Need.
But RHF, why try to reinvent the wheel? The Amateur Radio Service is
alreday recognized by most emergency organizations as the go to folks
when they need additionally capacity to handle communication duties.
Putting hundreds of thousands of FRS, GMRS, and CB's into the hands
every citizen will cause nothing but jammed frequencies and an
overloaded of panicked citizens all crying out for help at the same
time. Imagine 25,000 cb radios or FRS radios all transmitting at once
crying out for help....What you would have is nothing but a garbled
mess.
The first rule of emergency comms is to have a well defined plan that
consists of already trained folks who know how to use the equipment
they have, and are trained to prioritize the comms in a useful
manner. In reality, if folks feel that strong about it having the
capability, a ham ticket is easily obtained, and there are hams whoes
only interest in ham radio is emergency comms, training for it, and
support thereof.
Post by RHF
Every Citizen a Neighbor and Neightbors Helping
Neighbors in their Local Neighborhoods. ~ RHF
And how are they going to help, who is going to be able to handle the
"all at once" radio traffic that would barrage the EC under your
scenario. Even at the local level, such at a fire station, there
would not be enough staff to handle the traffic. Imagine 5000 calls
coming in at one time.
DL
DL,
CHOICE : Using the 'few' Technical Experts
-or- Empowering Each and Every US Citizen
To Help Themselves and Each Other in a
Local Emergency : Using the best of Today's
1 - Radio and TV {Internet}
* Emergency AM/FM Radio Crank-Up & Battery
2 - Cellphones and Telephones
3 - FRS + GMRS + CB Radios
4 - If All Else Fails Amateur Radio Operators
Sort of Like the Individual Citizens Right to . . .
Talkie-Talkie {2-Way Radio}
-aka- Right To Bear Arms {Be Prepared}
[Citizen's Self-Defense in a Natural Emergency]
+ 3-Days Safe Water Supply
+ 3-Days Canned Food
+ Emergency First Aid & Survival Kitshttp://www.campingsurvival.com/suremkit.htmlhttp://www.campingsurviva...
+ Emergency Signal Whistle / Safety Hornhttp://www.safetycentral.com/stormwhistle.htmlhttp://www.safetycentra...
+ Emergency AM/FM Radio Crank-Up & Battery
+ Emergency LED Lights Crank-Up & Battery
+ Emergency FRS + GMRS + CB Radios
+ Rain & Cold Weather Gear
+ Extra Blankets
* Coleman Storm Beam Dynamo Lanternhttp://www.mcsports.com/product/index.jsp?productId=3030061
* Coleman PerfectFlow Two-Mantle Propane Lanternhttp://www.safetycentral.com/copetwprla.html
* Kerosene Hurricane Lantern, 7.5" - 6 Candle Powerhttp://www.safetycentral.com/hurlan50ser.html
* ACE Camping Lanternhttp://www.acehardware.com/product/index.jsp?productId=1787728
i am not anti-hams - just 'pro' active citizenry ~ RHF
RHF, I am also pro-active citizenry. I certainly can agree that any
type of communication device which will allow you to communicate to
someone during an emergency is better than nothing at all.
However as you pointed out, I am thinking like a ham, I can't help but
at least try to plant a seed to increase the pool of ham radio
operators who could be used during emergencies.  Imagine if all
citizens were licensed (such as being part of the science ciriculum at
the elementary level), been trained to handle emergencies, and made
themselves available for at least one 12 hour shift during an
emergency.  What a wonderful concept, unrealistic I agree, but still
it would really show some good community sprit.
Nice topic and thread...73
DL
Question : What Today would be the Natural
Avenue for someone to Learn-Up to becoming
an Amateur {Ham} Radio Operator ?
Every Amateur Radio Club should offer a Class
in Emergency Communications for Citizens with
* What To Do in an Emergency
* Getting Prepared for a Local Emergency
* How To Use Your 2-Way Radios
* Going The Extra Step : How You Can Help Others
* What More . . . Become a Ham
idtars ~ RHF
fankly most clubs are not able to any such thing
RHF
2009-01-15 06:31:31 UTC
Permalink
- - DL - Think Long Term :
- -
- - Question : What Today would be the Natural
- - Avenue for someone to Learn-Up to becoming
- - an Amateur {Ham} Radio Operator ?
- -
- - Every Amateur Radio Club should offer a Class
- - in Emergency Communications for Citizens with
- - FRS, GMRS and CB Radios :
- - * What To Do in an Emergency
- - * Getting Prepared for a Local Emergency
- - * How To Use Your 2-Way Radios
- - * Going The Extra Step : How You Can Help Others
- - * What More . . . Become a Ham
- -
- - idtars ~ RHF

- fankly most clubs are not able to any such thing

aOF - Then 'potentially' the Amateur Radio Service
will effectively die-out within a generation. ~ RHF
.
.
Post by d***@hotmail.com
Post by RHF
Post by RHF
Post by d***@hotmail.com
Post by SC Dxing
A hurricane/snow storm can easily take out any antenna tower.
So me evidence to back up your claims. I've had multiple towers in
many locations and I've never lost one to a snow storm, ice storm,
hurricane, or tornado. Usually, the tower is the one thing that
survives.
Post by SC Dxing
Then you need electricity
Generators are fairly plentiful and run for days on 200 gallons of
propane.
Post by SC Dxing
Then you need someone who is going to listen on the
other side.
And hams do listen 24/7, somewhere in the world someone is always
listening. During Katrina, thounsands of traffic messages were passed,
as has many messages been handled during a lot of the ice storms this
season up North.
Post by SC Dxing
My wife works for emergency services and not a single
emergency scenario involves using ham radio operators.
Then they are not utilizing all the resources available to them.
Thankfully, my community involves all legitimate parties during every
emergency exercise, including ham radio ops, but CB radio and FRS are
never included because the folks who own FRS want to have a family CB
service, and CB radio ops are too busy trying to play who has the
biggest illegal amplfier. The users of CB and FRS do not have an
interest in emergency coms until something happens, then they show up
untrained, uncoordinated, and become an hinderance to any on going
operations.
Post by SC Dxing
If anything, CB radio or mobile UHF/VHF device would be more reliable.
Hams use UHF and VHF, so your point is??? And mobile CB is useless
more than 5-10 miles away unless you are running illegal power.
Post by SC Dxing
And a stationary HAM radio can only be used in one location.
And can relay messages locally from roving ops checking on health and
welfare, as well Statewide, Country wide, and World wide. Don't
forget that hams work in coordination with each other, some mobile,
and someone at the base with a tower relaying the information locally
or statewide as necessary.
Post by SC Dxing
Not very good, if you are going around house to house checking on people in an
emergency.
But ham radio can be used both portable and base, a repeater statioin
also comes to mind as a coordinated effort that has proven itself time
and time again.
Post by SC Dxing
A stationary tower is probably the worst choice for
emergency communications.
Why. Every emergeny service in the US uses stationary stations with
towers as the hub to their operations.
Post by SC Dxing
Satellite phone. Never ever goes out as long as you got it charged.
Never.
Most folks are not going to pay the outlandish monthly fees for a
satellite phone + air time. The only reason your sat phone works is
because not many folks have them. Just imagine if everyone had a sat
phone instead of a cell phone. I can tell you from experience that on
September 11, the whole cell phone infrastructure crashed and was not
operable.
If everyone had sat phones, it would overload the capablility of the
sat, and your phone would be worthless.
Post by SC Dxing
Post by RHF
sounds more like a towering monument to
someone's personal status and ego ~ RHF
.
Agreed. There was a time when a HAM radio operator was a real asset in
a disaster. But with the advances in technology, especially portable
communications, those days have passed.
So where were all of the so called advances when Katrina took out the
Gulf Coast? Or during the recent ice storms up North. Hams have
activiely assisted on both events and every major emergency in
between.
BTW, Which emergency organization does your wife work for, I would
like to find out why they are not adhering to the policies set forth
in the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) 2007 Appropriations Act
(HR 5441). Which indicates that Amateur Radio should be incorperated
into the contingent plans by all communities for emergency and
disaster prepardness.
DL
You may be able to help a few or many -but-What
about the hundreds of 'others' in need of H-E-L-P too ?
But the Average Citizen is NOT prepared : That Has
Got To Change : Putting a FRS, GMRS, and/or CB
Radio in the Hands of American Household can make
it possible to HELP Hundreds of People in Need.
But RHF, why try to reinvent the wheel? The Amateur Radio Service is
alreday recognized by most emergency organizations as the go to folks
when they need additionally capacity to handle communication duties.
Putting hundreds of thousands of FRS, GMRS, and CB's into the hands
every citizen will cause nothing but jammed frequencies and an
overloaded of panicked citizens all crying out for help at the same
time. Imagine 25,000 cb radios or FRS radios all transmitting at once
crying out for help....What you would have is nothing but a garbled
mess.
The first rule of emergency comms is to have a well defined plan that
consists of already trained folks who know how to use the equipment
they have, and are trained to prioritize the comms in a useful
manner. In reality, if folks feel that strong about it having the
capability, a ham ticket is easily obtained, and there are hams whoes
only interest in ham radio is emergency comms, training for it, and
support thereof.
Post by RHF
Every Citizen a Neighbor and Neightbors Helping
Neighbors in their Local Neighborhoods. ~ RHF
And how are they going to help, who is going to be able to handle the
"all at once" radio traffic that would barrage the EC under your
scenario. Even at the local level, such at a fire station, there
would not be enough staff to handle the traffic. Imagine 5000 calls
coming in at one time.
DL
DL,
CHOICE : Using the 'few' Technical Experts
-or- Empowering Each and Every US Citizen
To Help Themselves and Each Other in a
Local Emergency : Using the best of Today's
1 - Radio and TV {Internet}
* Emergency AM/FM Radio Crank-Up & Battery
2 - Cellphones and Telephones
3 - FRS + GMRS + CB Radios
4 - If All Else Fails Amateur Radio Operators
Sort of Like the Individual Citizens Right to . . .
Talkie-Talkie {2-Way Radio}
-aka- Right To Bear Arms {Be Prepared}
[Citizen's Self-Defense in a Natural Emergency]
+ 3-Days Safe Water Supply
+ 3-Days Canned Food
+ Emergency First Aid & Survival Kitshttp://www.campingsurvival.com/suremkit.htmlhttp://www.campingsurviva...
+ Emergency Signal Whistle / Safety Hornhttp://www.safetycentral.com/stormwhistle.htmlhttp://www.safetycentra...
+ Emergency AM/FM Radio Crank-Up & Battery
+ Emergency LED Lights Crank-Up & Battery
+ Emergency FRS + GMRS + CB Radios
+ Rain & Cold Weather Gear
+ Extra Blankets
* Coleman Storm Beam Dynamo Lanternhttp://www.mcsports.com/product/index.jsp?productId=3030061
* Coleman PerfectFlow Two-Mantle Propane Lanternhttp://www.safetycentral.com/copetwprla.html
* Kerosene Hurricane Lantern, 7.5" - 6 Candle Powerhttp://www.safetycentral.com/hurlan50ser.html
* ACE Camping Lanternhttp://www.acehardware.com/product/index.jsp?productId=1787728
i am not anti-hams - just 'pro' active citizenry ~ RHF
RHF, I am also pro-active citizenry. I certainly can agree that any
type of communication device which will allow you to communicate to
someone during an emergency is better than nothing at all.
However as you pointed out, I am thinking like a ham, I can't help but
at least try to plant a seed to increase the pool of ham radio
operators who could be used during emergencies.  Imagine if all
citizens were licensed (such as being part of the science ciriculum at
the elementary level), been trained to handle emergencies, and made
themselves available for at least one 12 hour shift during an
emergency.  What a wonderful concept, unrealistic I agree, but still
it would really show some good community sprit.
Nice topic and thread...73
DL
RHF
2009-01-11 03:55:58 UTC
Permalink
Post by Joe
Post by radioguy
They still wanted the ham tower completely gone.
I wonder who won. Click on
http://74.125.95.132/search?q=cache:aCVpkB3Ki2oJ:www.antennazoning.co...
Lets be honest here and not confuse the desire to erect and use large
antenna structures to facilitate DX'ing and other radio pursuits with
the proposition of providing 'emergency communications'.  I would
guess that 99.9% of the ham population never has or ever will provide
the types of 'emergency communications' to which you refer in support
of the erection of large towers and antenna arrays in deference to
zoning restrictions. Even while a vast majority continually chase the
holy grail of possessing a 'Big Gun' signal on the air.  The argument
sounds great till you actually tune around the bands during normal,
every day activity and maybe once in a while during a real emergency.
What you hear is the daily 'playing' of big gun radio operation.
Excessive power, excessive bandwidth used and nothing short of
electronic bullying/boasting of my signal is bigger than your signal.
When an emergency does occur a relatively small number of big gun
stations (usually located away from the big cities on large tracts of
expensive, desirable out of the way land where restrictions and
covenants do not even come into play) handling the brunt of the
communications. And a few passersbyes who may just listen or possibly
check in to alternate 'controll the onlookers' nets, so they can tell
their buddys and the uninitiated that they were helping out with one
disaster or another before they get bored with the whole thing and
move on to the latest must have dx or contest contact.
Lets be real.  Nothing wrong with Dx'ing and Contesting or any other
facet of the hobby.  But know that these are the real reason behind
many off the cuff fan the flame posts in support of knocking down
zoning rules and not a 'real' desire to provide an at the ready
emergency communications setup.
Been around long enough to know that truth!
.

Honestly - If everyone wanted and needed Emergency
Communications and the US Government wanted it's
Citizens to have Emergency Communications.

Then Every US Household and Every Car and Truck
would have one or all three of these :

1 - Family Radio Service (FRS)
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Family_Radio_Service

2 - General Mobile Radio Service (GMRS)
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/General_Mobile_Radio_Service

3 - Citizens' Band (CB) Radio

PLUS a 'Mandatory' Crank-Up and Battery
Powered Emergency AM & FM Radio
http://www.windandweather.com/product.asp?pcode=1392&crs=576&ref=product
http://www.weatherradiostore.com/mfgproduct.asp?mfgname=Eton&itmky=591335&mfgno=38

The-Bottom-Line : The Hams can't do it for the People :
The People Have To Do It For Themselves ~ RHF

Communicating During Emergencies
INFO - FCC Consumer Facts
http://www.fcc.gov/cgb/consumerfacts/emergencies.html
-note- Does Not Mention Amateur {Ham} Radio

Emergency Alert System (EAS) is on Radio and TV
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Emergency_Alert_System
http://www.fcc.gov/pshs/services/eas/
INFO - FCC Consumer Facts
http://www.fcc.gov/cgb/consumerfacts/eas.html
-history- Emergency Broadcast System (EBS)
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Emergency_Broadcast_System

NOAA Weather Radio Now Numbers 1000 Transmitters !
NWR = http://www.weather.gov/nwr/
NOAA Weather Radio All Hazards (NWR)

'Basic' Emergency Alert System (EAS) Radio
http://www.windandweather.com/product.asp?pcode=576
http://www.weatherradiostore.com/mfgproduct.asp?mfgname=Eton&itmky=79495&mfgno=38
http://dogbytecomputer.com/midland-wr-300-deluxe-s.a.m.e.-weather-alert-all-hazard-radio-with-am-fm.html

idtars ~ RHF
.
.
Dave
2009-01-11 13:22:52 UTC
Permalink
Post by RHF
Honestly - If everyone wanted and needed Emergency
Communications and the US Government wanted it's
Citizens to have Emergency Communications.
Then Every US Household and Every Car and Truck
1 - Family Radio Service (FRS)
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Family_Radio_Service
2 - General Mobile Radio Service (GMRS)
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/General_Mobile_Radio_Service
3 - Citizens' Band (CB) Radio
Will you quit being a dipshit? Have you ever been in an emergency e.g.
flash flood or wildfire? Do you think there are enough paid emergency
personnel to cover every street closure? To spot weather? To relay
information to the media?

Not everyone lives in the middle of nowhere.
RHF
2009-01-11 14:37:51 UTC
Permalink
Post by RHF
Honestly - If everyone wanted and needed Emergency
Communications and the US Government wanted it's
Citizens to have Emergency Communications.
Then Every US Household and Every Car and Truck
1 - Family Radio Service (FRS)
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Family_Radio_Service
2 - General Mobile Radio Service (GMRS)
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/General_Mobile_Radio_Service
3 - Citizens' Band (CB) Radio
- Will you quit being a dipshit?  Have you ever been in an emergency
e.g.
- flash flood or wildfire?  Do you think there are enough paid
emergency
- personnel to cover every street closure?  To spot weather?  To relay
- information to the media?
-
- Not everyone lives in the middle of nowhere.

Dave,

When the Power Goes "Off" for an Hour or More : Then
Everyone Lives in the Middle of an Electrical NoWhere :
* No{Where} AC for the TV / Radio
* No{Where} AC for the Internet / PC
* No{Where} AC for the Lights / Heater
* No{Where} AC for the Microwave / Coffee Pot
* No{Where} AC for the Refrigerator / Stove
* No{Where} AC for the Washer / Dryer
* * The 'basic' Home Phone may work but the
Cordless Phone and Cellphone just might not.
The only place most people have with News,
Lights and Heat is Setting in their Car or Truck
with the Engine Running and that is not good
to do in their Garages. {Best Done Outdoors
in the Drive Way and Off the Street.}

Dave - So it is 'being' a DipShit to recommended that :
"Then Every US Household and Every Car and Truck
would have one or all three of these :

1 - Family Radio Service (FRS)
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Family_Radio_Service

2 - General Mobile Radio Service (GMRS)
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/General_Mobile_Radio_Service

3 - Citizens' Band (CB) Radio
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Citizens%27_band_radio

PLUS a 'Mandatory' Crank-Up and Battery
Powered Emergency AM & FM Radio
http://www.windandweather.com/product.asp?pcode=1392&crs=576&ref=product
http://www.weatherradiostore.com/mfgproduct.asp?mfgname=Eton&itmky=59...

The-Bottom-Line : The Hams along can not
'do it' for the People : The People Have To
"Do It" For Themselves ~ RHF
.
HINT - BE PREPARED AND BE READY : SELF-RELIANCE
[ Yeah - I Know That's a DipShit {Common Sense} Idea ]
.
.
READ - FCC Consumer Facts :
* Communicating During Emergencies
* Emergency Alert System (EAS)
http://groups.google.com/group/rec.radio.shortwave/msg/13e354adad612ff6
.
dave - think ' c o n e l r a d ' ~ RHF
CONELRAD [CONtrol of ELectronic RADiation] System
http://www.fas.org/nuke/guide/usa/c3i/conelrad.htm
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/CONELRAD
http://www.oldradio.com/current/bc_conel.htm
.
.
Dave
2009-01-11 14:47:41 UTC
Permalink
Post by RHF
Honestly - If everyone wanted and needed Emergency
Communications and the US Government wanted it's
Citizens to have Emergency Communications.
Then Every US Household and Every Car and Truck
1 - Family Radio Service (FRS)
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Family_Radio_Service
2 - General Mobile Radio Service (GMRS)
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/General_Mobile_Radio_Service
3 - Citizens' Band (CB) Radio
- Will you quit being a dipshit? Have you ever been in an emergency
e.g.
- flash flood or wildfire? Do you think there are enough paid
emergency
- personnel to cover every street closure? To spot weather? To relay
- information to the media?
-
- Not everyone lives in the middle of nowhere.
Dave,
When the Power Goes "Off" for an Hour or More : Then
* No{Where} AC for the TV / Radio
* No{Where} AC for the Internet / PC
* No{Where} AC for the Lights / Heater
* No{Where} AC for the Microwave / Coffee Pot
* No{Where} AC for the Refrigerator / Stove
* No{Where} AC for the Washer / Dryer
* * The 'basic' Home Phone may work but the
Cordless Phone and Cellphone just might not.
The only place most people have with News,
Lights and Heat is Setting in their Car or Truck
with the Engine Running and that is not good
to do in their Garages. {Best Done Outdoors
in the Drive Way and Off the Street.}
"Then Every US Household and Every Car and Truck
1 - Family Radio Service (FRS)
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Family_Radio_Service
2 - General Mobile Radio Service (GMRS)
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/General_Mobile_Radio_Service
3 - Citizens' Band (CB) Radio
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Citizens%27_band_radio
Not everyone is comfortable on a two-way radio.
Ian Jackson
2009-01-11 15:31:17 UTC
Permalink
Post by Dave
Post by RHF
Honestly - If everyone wanted and needed Emergency
Communications and the US Government wanted it's
Citizens to have Emergency Communications.
Then Every US Household and Every Car and Truck
1 - Family Radio Service (FRS)
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Family_Radio_Service
2 - General Mobile Radio Service (GMRS)
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/General_Mobile_Radio_Service
3 - Citizens' Band (CB) Radio
- Will you quit being a dipshit? Have you ever been in an emergency
e.g.
- flash flood or wildfire? Do you think there are enough paid
emergency
- personnel to cover every street closure? To spot weather? To relay
- information to the media?
-
- Not everyone lives in the middle of nowhere.
Dave,
When the Power Goes "Off" for an Hour or More : Then
* No{Where} AC for the TV / Radio
* No{Where} AC for the Internet / PC
* No{Where} AC for the Lights / Heater
* No{Where} AC for the Microwave / Coffee Pot
* No{Where} AC for the Refrigerator / Stove
* No{Where} AC for the Washer / Dryer
* * The 'basic' Home Phone may work but the
Cordless Phone and Cellphone just might not.
The only place most people have with News,
Lights and Heat is Setting in their Car or Truck
with the Engine Running and that is not good
to do in their Garages. {Best Done Outdoors
in the Drive Way and Off the Street.}
"Then Every US Household and Every Car and Truck
1 - Family Radio Service (FRS)
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Family_Radio_Service
2 - General Mobile Radio Service (GMRS)
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/General_Mobile_Radio_Service
3 - Citizens' Band (CB) Radio
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Citizens%27_band_radio
Not everyone is comfortable on a two-way radio.
In a real emergency, the would soon learn to be 'comfortable'!
--
Ian
Dave
2009-01-11 18:09:02 UTC
Permalink
Post by Ian Jackson
Post by Dave
Post by RHF
Honestly - If everyone wanted and needed Emergency
Communications and the US Government wanted it's
Citizens to have Emergency Communications.
Then Every US Household and Every Car and Truck
1 - Family Radio Service (FRS)
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Family_Radio_Service
2 - General Mobile Radio Service (GMRS)
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/General_Mobile_Radio_Service
3 - Citizens' Band (CB) Radio
- Will you quit being a dipshit? Have you ever been in an emergency
e.g.
- flash flood or wildfire? Do you think there are enough paid
emergency
- personnel to cover every street closure? To spot weather? To relay
- information to the media?
-
- Not everyone lives in the middle of nowhere.
Dave,
When the Power Goes "Off" for an Hour or More : Then
* No{Where} AC for the TV / Radio
* No{Where} AC for the Internet / PC
* No{Where} AC for the Lights / Heater
* No{Where} AC for the Microwave / Coffee Pot
* No{Where} AC for the Refrigerator / Stove
* No{Where} AC for the Washer / Dryer
* * The 'basic' Home Phone may work but the
Cordless Phone and Cellphone just might not.
The only place most people have with News,
Lights and Heat is Setting in their Car or Truck
with the Engine Running and that is not good
to do in their Garages. {Best Done Outdoors
in the Drive Way and Off the Street.}
"Then Every US Household and Every Car and Truck
1 - Family Radio Service (FRS)
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Family_Radio_Service
2 - General Mobile Radio Service (GMRS)
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/General_Mobile_Radio_Service
3 - Citizens' Band (CB) Radio
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Citizens%27_band_radio
Not everyone is comfortable on a two-way radio.
In a real emergency, the would soon learn to be 'comfortable'!
An FRS radio goes a few miles. I can reach all of North America 24/7.
Amateur Radio is often the only infrastructure that survives a calamity.
SC Dxing
2009-01-11 19:59:41 UTC
Permalink
An FRS radio goes a few miles.  I can reach all of North America 24/7.
Amateur Radio is often the only infrastructure that survives a calamity.
A hurricane/snow storm can easily take out any antenna tower. Then you
need electricity, then you need someone who is going to listen on the
other side. My wife works for emergency services and not a single
emergency scenario involves using ham radio operators. If anything,
CB radio or mobile UHF/VHF device would be more reliable. And a
stationary HAM radio can only be used in one location. Not very good
if you are going around house to house checking on people in an
emergency. A stationary tower is probably the worst choice for
emergency communications.

Satellite phone. Never ever goes out as long as you got it charged.
Never.
Dave
2009-01-12 13:56:06 UTC
Permalink
Post by SC Dxing
Post by Dave
An FRS radio goes a few miles. I can reach all of North America 24/7.
Amateur Radio is often the only infrastructure that survives a calamity.
A hurricane/snow storm can easily take out any antenna tower. Then you
need electricity, then you need someone who is going to listen on the
other side. My wife works for emergency services and not a single
emergency scenario involves using ham radio operators. If anything,
CB radio or mobile UHF/VHF device would be more reliable. And a
stationary HAM radio can only be used in one location. Not very good
if you are going around house to house checking on people in an
emergency. A stationary tower is probably the worst choice for
emergency communications.
Satellite phone. Never ever goes out as long as you got it charged.
Never.
Has your wife actually been in an OEC? Ask her if there's an operating
position called RACES?

Amateur Radio includes MF/HF/VHF/UHF etc. Hams can be extremely
portable, way more so than a CB radio for instance.

http://www.areslax.org/
RHF
2009-01-12 14:03:11 UTC
Permalink
Post by SC Dxing
An FRS radio goes a few miles.  I can reach all of North America 24/7.
Amateur Radio is often the only infrastructure that survives a calamity.
A hurricane/snow storm can easily take out any antenna tower. Then you
need electricity, then you need someone who is going to listen on the
other side. My wife works for emergency services and not a single
emergency scenario involves using ham radio operators. If anything,
CB radio or mobile UHF/VHF device would be more reliable. And a
stationary HAM radio can only be used in one location. Not very good
if you are going around house to house checking on people in an
emergency. A stationary tower is probably the worst choice for
emergency communications.
Satellite phone. Never ever goes out as long as you got it charged.
Never.
Has your wife actually been in an OEC?  Ask her if there's an operating
position called RACES?
Amateur Radio includes MF/HF/VHF/UHF etc.  Hams can be extremely
portable, way more so than a CB radio for instance.
http://www.areslax.org/
Dave,

CB Radios in a Car or Truck are very 'portable'
and there are Way More of Them then Amateur
Radios. Add in FRS and GMRS Walkie-Talkies

D'Oh ! - What's more 'portable' than a Walkie-Talkie ?

FRS, GMRS and CB Radios : Simply Empowering
the People To Help Themselves in a Local Emergency.

idtars ~ RHF
.
Steve Stone
2009-01-12 17:37:49 UTC
Permalink
Post by SC Dxing
My wife works for emergency services and not a single
emergency scenario involves using ham radio operators.
That's a shame.
The ARES group I volunteer with is an integral part of my county and
hospital emergency comms.
Amateur radio is also the only reliable source of comms between the EOC
and nuke plant disaster field teams.
We are called out to provide comms every time the Delaware or Neversink
rivers flood.

There is more.. but you get my drift.

Steve
RHF
2009-01-11 20:12:40 UTC
Permalink
Post by Ian Jackson
Post by Dave
Post by RHF
Honestly - If everyone wanted and needed Emergency
Communications and the US Government wanted it's
Citizens to have Emergency Communications.
Then Every US Household and Every Car and Truck
1 - Family Radio Service (FRS)
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Family_Radio_Service
2 - General Mobile Radio Service (GMRS)
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/General_Mobile_Radio_Service
3 - Citizens' Band (CB) Radio
 - Will you quit being a dipshit?  Have you ever been in an emergency
e.g.
- flash flood or wildfire?  Do you think there are enough paid
emergency
- personnel to cover every street closure?  To spot weather?  To relay
- information to the media?
-
- Not everyone lives in the middle of nowhere.
 Dave,
 When the Power Goes "Off" for an Hour or More : Then
* No{Where} AC for the TV / Radio
* No{Where} AC for the Internet / PC
* No{Where} AC for the Lights / Heater
* No{Where} AC for the Microwave / Coffee Pot
* No{Where} AC for the Refrigerator / Stove
* No{Where} AC for the Washer / Dryer
* * The 'basic' Home Phone may work but the
Cordless Phone and Cellphone just might not.
The only place most people have with News,
Lights and Heat is Setting in their Car or Truck
with the Engine Running and that is not good
to do in their Garages. {Best Done Outdoors
in the Drive Way and Off the Street.}
"Then Every US Household and Every Car and Truck
 1 - Family Radio Service (FRS)
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Family_Radio_Service
 2 - General Mobile Radio Service (GMRS)
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/General_Mobile_Radio_Service
 3 - Citizens' Band (CB) Radio
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Citizens%27_band_radio
Not everyone is comfortable on a two-way radio.
In a real emergency, the would soon learn to be 'comfortable'!
- An FRS radio goes a few miles.
- I can reach all of North America 24/7.
- Amateur Radio is often the only
- infrastructure that survives a calamity.

And if the local Hams in a Neighborhood had a Plan
to go to the local Neighborhood Fire Stations and
not only man Amateur Radio by FRS, GMRS and
CB then they would be Helping All the People in
Need within the '"Few [Square] Miles" of their own
local Neighborhood.

The-Bottom-Line : Helping Your Neighbors In
A Local Emergency Does Not Require a Nation
Wide ComLine. Reliable Local Communications
Is What Is Required To Identify People In-Need
And Get Them H-E-L-P !

Lets See 5~10 Amateur Radio Operators -or-
50~200 Local Citizens with FRS, GMRS and
CB Radios in each Local Neighborhood: I Say
Go With The Local Citizens.

idtars ~ RHF
.
h***@att.net
2009-01-11 22:30:47 UTC
Permalink
On Sun, 11 Jan 2009 12:12:40 -0800 (PST), RHF
Post by RHF
Post by Ian Jackson
Post by Dave
Post by RHF
Honestly - If everyone wanted and needed Emergency
Communications and the US Government wanted it's
Citizens to have Emergency Communications.
Then Every US Household and Every Car and Truck
1 - Family Radio Service (FRS)
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Family_Radio_Service
2 - General Mobile Radio Service (GMRS)
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/General_Mobile_Radio_Service
3 - Citizens' Band (CB) Radio
 - Will you quit being a dipshit?  Have you ever been in an emergency
e.g.
- flash flood or wildfire?  Do you think there are enough paid
emergency
- personnel to cover every street closure?  To spot weather?  To relay
- information to the media?
-
- Not everyone lives in the middle of nowhere.
 Dave,
 When the Power Goes "Off" for an Hour or More : Then
* No{Where} AC for the TV / Radio
* No{Where} AC for the Internet / PC
* No{Where} AC for the Lights / Heater
* No{Where} AC for the Microwave / Coffee Pot
* No{Where} AC for the Refrigerator / Stove
* No{Where} AC for the Washer / Dryer
* * The 'basic' Home Phone may work but the
Cordless Phone and Cellphone just might not.
The only place most people have with News,
Lights and Heat is Setting in their Car or Truck
with the Engine Running and that is not good
to do in their Garages. {Best Done Outdoors
in the Drive Way and Off the Street.}
"Then Every US Household and Every Car and Truck
 1 - Family Radio Service (FRS)
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Family_Radio_Service
 2 - General Mobile Radio Service (GMRS)
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/General_Mobile_Radio_Service
 3 - Citizens' Band (CB) Radio
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Citizens%27_band_radio
Not everyone is comfortable on a two-way radio.
In a real emergency, the would soon learn to be 'comfortable'!
- An FRS radio goes a few miles.
- I can reach all of North America 24/7.
- Amateur Radio is often the only
- infrastructure that survives a calamity.
And if the local Hams in a Neighborhood had a Plan
to go to the local Neighborhood Fire Stations and
not only man Amateur Radio by FRS, GMRS and
CB then they would be Helping All the People in
Need within the '"Few [Square] Miles" of their own
local Neighborhood.
The-Bottom-Line : Helping Your Neighbors In
A Local Emergency Does Not Require a Nation
Wide ComLine. Reliable Local Communications
Is What Is Required To Identify People In-Need
And Get Them H-E-L-P !
Lets See 5~10 Amateur Radio Operators -or-
50~200 Local Citizens with FRS, GMRS and
CB Radios in each Local Neighborhood: I Say
Go With The Local Citizens.
idtars ~ RHF
.
Some of us hams use radios that are WIDE OPEN!
Try talking to FEMA with FRS.
Mike
2009-01-12 00:58:20 UTC
Permalink
Post by h***@att.net
Some of us hams use radios that are WIDE OPEN!
Try talking to FEMA with FRS.
Which is illegal as your hammy radios are not FCC type accepted for
operation outside of the hammy bands.
an_old_friend
2009-01-12 01:10:10 UTC
Permalink
Post by Mike
Post by h***@att.net
Some of us hams use radios that are WIDE OPEN!
Try talking to FEMA with FRS.
Which is illegal as your hammy radios are not FCC type accepted for
operation outside of the hammy bands.
no as a point it is not ilegal; at all ...."no part of these rules
shall restarin a station from acting in an emergency"


hard to plan for etc given it is not even legal to drill for but doing
it in a pinch is quite legal
Mike
2009-01-12 02:11:49 UTC
Permalink
On Sun, 11 Jan 2009 17:10:10 -0800 (PST), an_old_friend
Post by an_old_friend
Post by Mike
Post by h***@att.net
Some of us hams use radios that are WIDE OPEN!
Try talking to FEMA with FRS.
Which is illegal as your hammy radios are not FCC type accepted for
operation outside of the hammy bands.
no as a point it is not ilegal; at all ...."no part of these rules
shall restarin a station from acting in an emergency"
WOW....The line you quoted....Is it that full of misspelled words?
How do you "restarin" a station?
an_old_friend
2009-01-12 02:38:50 UTC
Permalink
Post by Mike
On Sun, 11 Jan 2009 17:10:10 -0800 (PST), an_old_friend
Post by an_old_friend
Post by Mike
Post by h***@att.net
Some of us hams use radios that are WIDE OPEN!
Try talking to FEMA with FRS.
Which is illegal as your hammy radios are not FCC type accepted for
operation outside of the hammy bands.
no as a point it is not ilegal; at all ...."no part of these rules
shall restarin a station from acting in an emergency"
WOW....The line you quoted....Is it that full of misspelled words?
How do you "restarin" a station?
fuck off but you made my point if all yuo can do is play spelling nazi
you conceed I am right
Mike
2009-01-13 02:49:23 UTC
Permalink
On Sun, 11 Jan 2009 18:38:50 -0800 (PST), an_old_friend
Post by an_old_friend
Post by Mike
On Sun, 11 Jan 2009 17:10:10 -0800 (PST), an_old_friend
Post by an_old_friend
Post by Mike
Post by h***@att.net
Some of us hams use radios that are WIDE OPEN!
Try talking to FEMA with FRS.
Which is illegal as your hammy radios are not FCC type accepted for
operation outside of the hammy bands.
no as a point it is not ilegal; at all ...."no part of these rules
shall restarin a station from acting in an emergency"
WOW....The line you quoted....Is it that full of misspelled words?
How do you "restarin" a station?
fuck off but you made my point if all yuo can do is play spelling nazi
you conceed I am right
Dude, are you retarded or something?
d***@hotmail.com
2009-01-12 01:17:35 UTC
Permalink
Post by Mike
Post by h***@att.net
Some of us hams use radios that are WIDE OPEN!
Try talking to FEMA with FRS.
Which is illegal as your hammy radios are not FCC type accepted for
operation outside of the hammy bands.
However, there are hams who also work or volunteer in the emergency
response field who have "type accepted" equipment that is loaded with
both their local municipalities frequencies and ham radio frequencies,
and do legally use both sets of frequencies as necessary. As long as
the equipment is type accepted and the user is authorized to use the
municipalities frequencies, there is no problem nor is it illegal.

DL.
Mike
2009-01-12 02:10:00 UTC
Permalink
Post by d***@hotmail.com
Post by Mike
Post by h***@att.net
Some of us hams use radios that are WIDE OPEN!
Try talking to FEMA with FRS.
Which is illegal as your hammy radios are not FCC type accepted for
operation outside of the hammy bands.
However, there are hams who also work or volunteer in the emergency
response field who have "type accepted" equipment that is loaded with
both their local municipalities frequencies and ham radio frequencies,
and do legally use both sets of frequencies as necessary. As long as
the equipment is type accepted and the user is authorized to use the
municipalities frequencies, there is no problem nor is it illegal.
DL.
Read the original post. The reference was to radios that are "wide
open", meaning hammy gear that has been modified. The situation you
describe is NOT the same, but I agree, it is legal. Hammy gear is not
type-accepted for use outside of the hammy bands.
d***@hotmail.com
2009-01-12 02:41:39 UTC
Permalink
Post by d***@hotmail.com
Post by Mike
Post by h***@att.net
Some of us hams use radios that are WIDE OPEN!
Try talking to FEMA with FRS.
Which is illegal as your hammy radios are not FCC type accepted for
operation outside of the hammy bands.
However, there are hams who also work or volunteer in the emergency
response field who have "type accepted" equipment that is loaded with
both their local municipalities frequencies and ham radio frequencies,
and do legally use both sets of frequencies as necessary. �As long as
the equipment is type accepted and the user is authorized to use the
municipalities frequencies, there is no problem nor is it illegal.
DL.
Read the original post. �The reference was to radios that are "wide
open", meaning hammy gear that has been modified. �The situation you
describe is NOT the same, but I agree, it is legal. �Hammy gear is not
type-accepted for use outside of the hammy bands.- Hide quoted text -
- Show quoted text -
Then we are on the same page, I stand corrected.


DL
an_old_friend
2009-01-12 02:51:54 UTC
Permalink
On Jan 11, 9:41 pm, ***@hotmail.com wrote:
geta real name or call freak
d***@hotmail.com
2009-01-12 21:40:31 UTC
Permalink
geta �real name or call freak
Ahem, you are more of a freak, pest. Now stop trying to hi-jack this
thread. Calm down and go away like a good little boy.
an_old_friend
2009-01-12 22:33:08 UTC
Permalink
Post by d***@hotmail.com
geta real name or call freak
Ahem, you are more of a freak, pest.
no I am normal you OTOH are ashamed to even give your name
Post by d***@hotmail.com
Now stop trying to hi-jack this
thread.  
you are trying to hijack it not me to try and establish cred for your
coward routine
Post by d***@hotmail.com
Calm down and go away like a good little boy.
we all know you are sexauly obessed with little boys but go mgte
treatemtn sicko
an_old_friend
2009-01-12 22:33:52 UTC
Permalink
Post by d***@hotmail.com
geta real name or call freak
Ahem, you are more of a freak, pest.
no I am normal you OTOH are ashamed to even give your name
Post by d***@hotmail.com
Now stop trying to hi-jack this
thread.  
you are trying to hijack it not me to try and establish cred for your
coward routine
Post by d***@hotmail.com
Calm down and go away like a good little boy.
we all know you are sexauly obessed with little boys but go mgte
treatemtn sicko
Mike
2009-01-13 02:57:56 UTC
Permalink
Post by d***@hotmail.com
- Show quoted text -
Then we are on the same page, I stand corrected.
DL
Sounds like you are involved with some type of emergency response.
God bless, my friend.
radioguy
2009-01-15 07:59:22 UTC
Permalink
Post by d***@hotmail.com
Post by Mike
Post by h***@att.net
Some of us hams use radios that are WIDE OPEN!
Try talking to FEMA with FRS.
Which is illegal as your hammy radios are not FCC type accepted for
operation outside of the hammy bands.
However, there are hams who also work or volunteer in the emergency
response field who have "type accepted" equipment that is loaded with
both their local municipalities frequencies and ham radio frequencies,
and do legally use both sets of frequencies as necessary.  As long as
the equipment is type accepted and the user is authorized to use the
municipalities frequencies, there is no problem nor is it illegal.
DL.
Read the original post.  The reference was to radios that are "wide
open", meaning hammy gear that has been modified.  The situation you
describe is NOT the same, but I agree, it is legal.  Hammy gear is not
type-accepted for use outside of the hammy bands.- Hide quoted text -
My ham radio is type accepted by the FCC and can transmit on police
frequencies without any modifications at all.

However, I do not do that. I value my license.

However the problem is that I now hear from some people, or more
accurately read from them, that mere possession of such is illegal.

I did not know that when I bought it brand new from a major ham store
straight as it came from the factory.

And the FCC rules did not say that possession of such is illegal. As a
matter of fact, according to the fcc rules, it's just the opposite.

Although I did read some state laws say possession of such is illegal.

What happened to "federal law always trumps local and state law" that
99.99 percent of the hams on here claimed???

The FCC rules even say I can transmit on those particular frequencies,
just not from my home, only while I'm mobile.

So under FCC rules, I'm allowed to transmit on them while mobile from
certain locations, but not allowed to transmit on them while
stationary at home.

While I'm sure the police in states claiming possession of such is
illegal will say just exactly the opposite of the above.
- Show quoted text -
radioguy
2009-01-15 07:46:18 UTC
Permalink
Post by d***@hotmail.com
Post by Mike
Post by h***@att.net
Some of us hams use radios that are WIDE OPEN!
Try talking to FEMA with FRS.
Which is illegal as your hammy radios are not FCC type accepted for
operation outside of the hammy bands.
okay. It's proof time for me.

I have an unmodified ham radio bought directly from a major ham store
brand new by me, which straight from the factory, can indeed transmit
on
some police channels.

You seem to claim it's illegal to even have such a radio since I'm not
licensed to transmit on police frequncies.

However, the FCC rules clearly say that I can transmit regular ham
radio on those exact same police frequencies even where the police can
hear me
doing so as long as I'm 1. transmitting from certain locations and 2.
not interfering with them (such as not transmitting over the polic
while they're talking, bt if they're quiet, it's okay for me to
transmit on the same channel).
Post by d***@hotmail.com
However, there are hams who also work or volunteer in the emergency
response field who have "type accepted" equipment that is loaded with
both their local municipalities frequencies and ham radio frequencies,
and do legally use both sets of frequencies as necessary.  As long as
the equipment is type accepted and the user is authorized to use the
municipalities frequencies, there is no problem nor is it illegal.
DL.
Dave
2009-01-15 13:12:57 UTC
Permalink
Post by radioguy
However, the FCC rules clearly say that I can transmit regular ham
radio on those exact same police frequencies even where the police can
hear me
doing so as long as I'm 1. transmitting from certain locations and 2.
not interfering with them (such as not transmitting over the polic
while they're talking, bt if they're quiet, it's okay for me to
transmit on the same channel).
This is getting interesting. Tell me more.
radioguy
2009-01-15 23:45:30 UTC
Permalink
Post by Dave
Post by radioguy
However, the FCC rules clearly say that I can transmit regular ham
radio on those exact same police frequencies even where the police can
hear me
doing so as long as I'm 1. transmitting from certain locations and 2.
not interfering with them (such as not transmitting over the polic
while they're talking, bt if they're  quiet, it's okay for me to
transmit on the same channel).
This is getting interesting. Tell me more.
In the U.S., the 420 to 430 mhz band is assigned to the police, public
safety, and I think even some businesses north of line A.

FCC rules say a ham is NOT allowed to transmit on those frequencies
while physically located north of line A.

FCC rules say that the same ham IS allowed to transmit with full power
on those frequencies while physically located south of line A as long
as
the ham south of line A does not cause any interference to the
licensed services located north of line A.

Questions: If I'm just a little south of line A and transmitting ham
ragchews at a certain power level where the police in the next county
north of line A can not hear me on their radios, am I transmitting
legally or illegally?

I say legally. BUT

Say I make no change in my transmitter whatsoever and the police in
the next county happen to buy newer more sensitive radios and can now
just
happen to hear me transmitting over them. With me unaware they can now
hear me. Am I transmitting legally or illegally.

I made no changes whatsoever in my transmitter.

How can what was perfectly legal for me to do now be illegal for me to
do just because the police not in my area bought different newer
radios that happen to pick up radio transmissions better than their
old ones???

Furthermore, if a police officer sees a crime or speeder in his own
county, he is allowed to follow them into the next county and arrest
them there.

What if he crosses into the county south of line A and transmits from
there, but hears me.

As far as I know, he isn't legally allowed to transmit from south of
line A.

However, despite a lot of hams I see posting on the internet claiming
that hams have primary status in the 420 to 430 mhz band, I know that
hams
actually only have secondary status in that band, anywhere in the
country.

However, I don't think local police have anyathority in that band
south of line A, although I might be wrong about that.

After all, the FCC does say that even hams south of line A may not
interfere with police north of line A.

But what if that police officer travels south of line A where I'm sure
he's not allowed to transmit from?

I think it's only the federal government (and maybe some others) who
have primary status in that band, anywhere in the country.

I'll have to check up on that.
RHF
2009-01-16 02:41:10 UTC
Permalink
Post by radioguy
Post by Dave
Post by radioguy
However, the FCC rules clearly say that I can transmit regular ham
radio on those exact same police frequencies even where the police can
hear me
doing so as long as I'm 1. transmitting from certain locations and 2.
not interfering with them (such as not transmitting over the polic
while they're talking, bt if they're  quiet, it's okay for me to
transmit on the same channel).
This is getting interesting. Tell me more.
In the U.S., the 420 to 430 mhz band is assigned to the police, public
safety, and I think even some businesses north of line A.
FCC rules say a ham is NOT allowed to transmit on those frequencies
while physically located north of line A.
FCC rules say that the same ham IS allowed to transmit with full power
on those frequencies while physically located south of line A as long
as
the ham south of line A does not cause any interference to the
licensed services located north of line A.
Questions: If I'm just a little south of line A and transmitting  ham
ragchews at a certain power level where the police in the next county
north of line A can not hear me on their radios, am I transmitting
legally or illegally?
I say legally. BUT
Say I make no change in my transmitter whatsoever and the police in
the next county happen to buy newer more sensitive radios and can now
just
happen to hear me transmitting over them. With me unaware they can now
hear me. Am I transmitting legally or illegally.
I made no changes whatsoever in my transmitter.
How can what was perfectly legal for me to do now be illegal for me to
do just because the police not in my area bought different newer
radios that happen to pick up radio transmissions better than their
old ones???
Furthermore, if a police officer sees a crime or speeder in his own
county, he is allowed to follow them into the next county and arrest
them there.
What if he crosses into the county south of line A and transmits from
there, but hears me.
As far as I know, he isn't legally allowed to transmit from south of
line A.
However, despite a lot of hams I see posting on the internet claiming
that hams have primary status in the 420 to 430 mhz band, I know that
hams
actually only have secondary status in that band, anywhere in the
country.
However, I don't think local police have anyathority in that band
south of line A, although I might be wrong about that.
After all, the FCC does say that even hams south of line A may not
interfere with police north of line A.
But what if that police officer travels south of line A where I'm sure
he's not allowed to transmit from?
I think it's only the federal government (and maybe some others) who
have primary status in that band, anywhere in the country.
I'll have to check up on that.
Another one of RadioGuy's absurd "Troll Story"s
-aka- 'war and peace' on the internet ~ RHF
.
Mike
2009-01-16 14:46:49 UTC
Permalink
Post by RHF
Another one of RadioGuy's absurd "Troll Story"s
-aka- 'war and peace' on the internet ~ RHF
RHF, do you mean Troll Stories? For goodness sake, man, try to use
English! At least I could understand what Radioguy was writing. Your
misuse of words, your use of incorrect punctuation, and your spelling
makes your efforts at being a netnanny seem like irony.

Get a clue, Roy. I refuse to believe that you are as stupid as your
posts make you look. A college student writing like you do on this
newsgroup would flunk out of English 101.

Mike
RHF
2009-01-16 15:54:16 UTC
Permalink
- - Another one of RadioGuy's absurd "Troll Story"s
- - -aka- 'war and peace' on the internet ~ RHF

- RHF, do you mean Troll Stories?
- For goodness sake, man, try to use English!
- At least I could understand what Radioguy was writing.
- Your misuse of words, your use of incorrect punctuation,
- and your spelling makes your efforts at being a netnanny
- seem like irony.
-
- Get a clue, Roy. I refuse to believe that you are
- as stupid as your posts make you look.
- A college student writing like you do on this
- newsgroup would flunk out of English 101.
-
- Mike

MWB - Yeah I Be - Dumber Than Dumb ~ RHF

=SOURCE=
Subject : Are hams terrorists?
http://groups.google.com/group/rec.radio.shortwave/msg/1dfe98f2413b40f0
- Not necessary, I did not respond to the story,
- I responded to Radioguy's post,
- reporting a blatant troll story.
-
- 73 DL
.
"Troll Story" - 'war and peace' on the internet ~ RHF
.
MWB a 'play' on the name of "Leo Tolstoy"
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Leo_Tolstoy
-hence- 'Troll Story' -singular- and the
-reference-to- 'war and peace'
.
-thus-followed- My Reply
Another one of RadioGuy's absurd "Troll Story"s
-aka- 'war and peace' on the internet ~ RHF
.
"Tolstoy"s ~ "Troll Story"s
.
See there MWB - I did not have to call you
'stupid' or suggest that you would 'flunk out'
of Engfish Zero-Prime-Zero. ~ RHF
.
-ps- MWB - I am not here to impress you with
my use of the American {English} Language :
I am simply here to enjoy* myself being myself.
* enjoy = enjoyable = enjoyment {Me Being Me}
.
MWB - Just For You - I Have Changed the Subject-Line
to : (OT) : PONG RadioGuy -another- "Troll Story"
.
Dave
2009-01-12 14:04:11 UTC
Permalink
Post by Mike
Post by h***@att.net
Some of us hams use radios that are WIDE OPEN!
Try talking to FEMA with FRS.
Which is illegal as your hammy radios are not FCC type accepted for
operation outside of the hammy bands.
During an emergency, when immediate aid is required, you may use any
frequency likely to facilitate getting that assistance.
Steve Stone
2009-01-12 17:57:12 UTC
Permalink
Post by Mike
Which is illegal as your hammy radios are not FCC type accepted for
operation outside of the hammy bands.
Actually, the FCC states that during an emergency, hams can use whatever
freqs get the job done, even outside of the ham bands.
h***@att.net
2009-01-12 23:25:15 UTC
Permalink
Post by Mike
Post by h***@att.net
Some of us hams use radios that are WIDE OPEN!
Try talking to FEMA with FRS.
Which is illegal as your hammy radios are not FCC type accepted for
operation outside of the hammy bands.
Bull! Ever here of M.A.R.S.
an_old_friend
2009-01-13 02:09:26 UTC
Permalink
Post by h***@att.net
Post by Mike
Post by h***@att.net
Some of us hams use radios that are WIDE OPEN!
Try talking to FEMA with FRS.
Which is illegal as your hammy radios are not FCC type accepted for
operation outside of the hammy bands.
Bull! Ever here of M.A.R.S.
don't cnfuse th3se guys with facts
Mike
2009-01-13 02:48:39 UTC
Permalink
Post by h***@att.net
Post by Mike
Post by h***@att.net
Some of us hams use radios that are WIDE OPEN!
Try talking to FEMA with FRS.
Which is illegal as your hammy radios are not FCC type accepted for
operation outside of the hammy bands.
Bull! Ever here of M.A.R.S.
We are talking about VHF and UHF, not HF.
Brenda Ann
2009-01-13 03:10:06 UTC
Permalink
Post by Mike
Post by h***@att.net
Post by Mike
Post by h***@att.net
Some of us hams use radios that are WIDE OPEN!
Try talking to FEMA with FRS.
Which is illegal as your hammy radios are not FCC type accepted for
operation outside of the hammy bands.
Bull! Ever here of M.A.R.S.
We are talking about VHF and UHF, not HF.
There are MARS frequencies on both VHF and UHF.
radioguy
2009-01-15 07:40:03 UTC
Permalink
Post by Mike
Post by h***@att.net
Some of us hams use radios that are WIDE OPEN!
Try talking to FEMA with FRS.
Which is illegal as your hammy radios are not FCC type accepted for
operation outside of the hammy bands.
I have a ham radio I bought at the ham store that came directly from
the manufacturer which can transmit on the police channels without
any
modification at all.

And yes, it was manufactured by a major ham radio manufacturer, not by
some fly-by-night company.

And it is FCC type accepted.

However, I do not transmit on the police channels.

I definitely don't want to lose my liceense.

Nor end up in jail.

I'm not rich.

Even the "small" amount to take the tests is a "big" amount for me.

The problem is I have now read that it is illegal to even have a radio
that is capable of transmitting on police channels.

Since my radio is capable of transmitting on some police channels, is
it an illegal radio or not?

Looking at the FCC rules, it isn't.

And I can prove that.
radioguy
2009-01-15 08:31:45 UTC
Permalink
Post by Mike
Post by h***@att.net
Some of us hams use radios that are WIDE OPEN!
Try talking to FEMA with FRS.
Which is illegal as your hammy radios are not FCC type accepted for
operation outside of the hammy bands.
The EMS service in my area uses one of the frs-only channels

Both for dspatch and communications.

And the.police use one of the frs-only

For communicationm\ns involving following vehicles and reading the
license plate numbers of the vehicles over the air.

Is it illegal for me to possess my frs.gmrs radios since they are
capable of transmtting on frequencie used by the police and ems??

Is it illegal for me to transmit on those frs-only channels since
they're police and ems channels?????

The federal FCC rules say they are shared channels that anyone may
use.

However, there have already been people in other cities and other
states arrested for illegally transmitting over police channels when
those police
channels were on the frs channels.

It seems like federal law did not trump local and state law in those
cases despite what 99.99 percent of the hams on here have said.

And even when people can get out of it, it still costs them in court
costs and lawyers fees.

The kind of money that I do not have and would not be able to get out
of in such a case.

So yes you can be fined, found guilty and put in jail for legally
transmitting on your frs/gmrs radio even when you don't hear anyone
else transmitting
on that channel since you are illegally transmitting on a police
channel or ems channel by doing so (as far as local police, local
government and some states are concerned).

Even if it is one of the frs-only channels (eight through fourteen on
the radios I've seen).

I'm not sure if what I heard is my local town or one of the other
towns very close to me.

However, the police and ems are definitely using the frs-only channels
as a police channel and an ems channel. (two different channels, one
each that I have heard so far).

According to the FCC rules I've read, that is legal for them to use as
such since frs may be used by anyone including businesses or by anyone
period.

Bt once again, (concerning the arrests of people for transmitting on
frs-only channels) what happened to federal law always trumps local
and state law???
radioguy
2009-01-15 23:11:08 UTC
Permalink
Post by radioguy
Post by Mike
Post by h***@att.net
Some of us hams use radios that are WIDE OPEN!
Try talking to FEMA with FRS.
Which is illegal as your hammy radios are not FCC type accepted for
operation outside of the hammy bands.
The EMS service in my area uses one of the frs-only channels
Both for dspatch and communications.
And the.police use one of the frs-only
For communicationm\ns involving following vehicles and reading the
license plate numbers of the vehicles over the air.
Is it illegal for me to possess my frs.gmrs radios since they are
capable of transmtting on frequencie used by the police and ems??
Is it illegal for me to transmit on those frs-only channels since
they're police and ems channels?????
The federal FCC rules say they are shared channels that anyone may
use.
However, there have already been people in other cities and other
states arrested for illegally transmitting over police channels when
those police
channels were on the frs channels.
It seems like federal law did not trump local and state law in those
cases despite what 99.99 percent of the hams on here have said.
And even when people can get out of it, it still costs them in court
costs and lawyers fees.
The kind of money that I do not have and would not be able to get out
of in such a case.
So yes you can be fined, found guilty and put in jail for legally
transmitting on your frs/gmrs radio even when you don't hear anyone
else transmitting
on that channel since you are illegally transmitting on a police
channel or ems channel by doing so (as far as local police, local
government and some states are concerned).
Even if it is one of the frs-only channels (eight through fourteen on
the radios I've seen).
I'm not sure if what I heard is my local town or one of the other
towns very close to me.
However, the police and ems are definitely using the frs-only channels
as a police channel and an ems channel. (two different channels, one
each that I have heard so far).
According to the FCC rules I've read, that is legal for them to use as
such since frs may be used by anyone including businesses or by anyone
period.
Bt once again, (concerning the arrests of people for transmitting on
frs-only channels) what happened to federal law always trumps local
and state law???
RadioGuy,
More Ham Radio This and Ham Radio That
- - - yada, Yada. YADA !
The-Bottom-Line : It is Clearly Illegal for 'you' to
knowingly Interfere with Official Public Service
Radio Operations on Any Frequency [.]
- - - Being an Amateur Radio Operator has it limits.
Plus - It is Clearly Illegal for you to knowingly
Interfere with {get-in-the-way-of} Official Public
Service Operations at Any Location [.]
- - - Being an Involved Citizen has it limits.
now go and enjoy your radios ~ RHF
-ps- please stay-out of the way of public
service employees doing their jobs.
.- Hide quoted text -
- Show quoted text -
I did not say it's legal to interfere with the police. It's not. I
even said the FCC rules say that we're not allowed to interfere with
the police.

However, I do not consider transmitting on a frs channel that no one
else is talking on at the time as "interfering with the police" even
if the police
say so because they think the shared frs channels are their own
private police channels.

What if I had never heard them on there in the first place, which
could have happened since I very rarely have my frs radios on.

I turn to frs channel 8, hear no one talking, so transmit to the other
person I'm talking to, and get arrested for "illegally transmitting on
a police channel".

I try to get out of it by truthfully saying I didn't know it's a
police channel.

They and the court then come back with "Ignorance of the law is no
excuse".

But wait, the federal FCC rules says the channels are for everyone as
long as no interference is caused.

However, even though the police were not talking at the time, but were
listening, they consider it as interference being caused to their own
private
family radio servvice police channel.

While I consider it as interference not happening since no
conversations were on the channel at the time I was listening and
transmitting.

Once again, what happened to federal law trumps all local and state
laws?

I'm no rich enough to fight it in court.

So you're basically saying that no one in the general public is
allowed to use the frs-only channels even though the fedeal FCC says
the can, since
a number of public safety agencies inclding the police and ems have
decided to use the frs-only channels as their own private publicv
safety channels.

EMS channel 8. Police channel 14. Etcetera.

This forces the general public to illegally use channels 1-7 and 15
throguh 22, since they can't use channels 7 through 14 without getting
arrested by
the police for illegally using police channels.

I wonder what John Wilkerson would say about that.

Of course, the public would also be fined and arrested by the FCC and
federal marshalls for illegally using channela 1 through 7 and 15
through 22.
Mike
2009-01-16 00:24:07 UTC
Permalink
On Thu, 15 Jan 2009 15:11:08 -0800 (PST), radioguy
Post by radioguy
RadioGuy,
More Ham Radio This and Ham Radio That
- - - yada, Yada. YADA !
The-Bottom-Line : It is Clearly Illegal for 'you' to
knowingly Interfere with Official Public Service
Radio Operations on Any Frequency [.]
- - - Being an Amateur Radio Operator has it limits.
Plus - It is Clearly Illegal for you to knowingly
Interfere with {get-in-the-way-of} Official Public
Service Operations at Any Location [.]
- - - Being an Involved Citizen has it limits.
now go and enjoy your radios ~ RHF
-ps- please stay-out of the way of public
service employees doing their jobs.
.- Hide quoted text -
- Show quoted text -
I did not say it's legal to interfere with the police. It's not. I
even said the FCC rules say that we're not allowed to interfere with
the police.
However, I do not consider transmitting on a frs channel that no one
else is talking on at the time as "interfering with the police" even
if the police
say so because they think the shared frs channels are their own
private police channels.
What if I had never heard them on there in the first place, which
could have happened since I very rarely have my frs radios on.
I turn to frs channel 8, hear no one talking, so transmit to the other
person I'm talking to, and get arrested for "illegally transmitting on
a police channel".
I try to get out of it by truthfully saying I didn't know it's a
police channel.
They and the court then come back with "Ignorance of the law is no
excuse".
But wait, the federal FCC rules says the channels are for everyone as
long as no interference is caused.
However, even though the police were not talking at the time, but were
listening, they consider it as interference being caused to their own
private
family radio servvice police channel.
While I consider it as interference not happening since no
conversations were on the channel at the time I was listening and
transmitting.
Once again, what happened to federal law trumps all local and state
laws?
I'm no rich enough to fight it in court.
So you're basically saying that no one in the general public is
allowed to use the frs-only channels even though the fedeal FCC says
the can, since
a number of public safety agencies inclding the police and ems have
decided to use the frs-only channels as their own private publicv
safety channels.
EMS channel 8. Police channel 14. Etcetera.
This forces the general public to illegally use channels 1-7 and 15
throguh 22, since they can't use channels 7 through 14 without getting
arrested by
the police for illegally using police channels.
I wonder what John Wilkerson would say about that.
Of course, the public would also be fined and arrested by the FCC and
federal marshalls for illegally using channela 1 through 7 and 15
through 22.
Radioguy is going to make Bubba in prison VERY happy and satisfied.
He'll be cell block 9's favorite bitch.
radioguy
2009-01-17 15:14:38 UTC
Permalink
Post by Mike
Radioguy is going to make Bubba in prison VERY happy and satisfied.
He'll be cell block 9's favorite bitch.- Hide quoted text -
- Show quoted text -
I would like to disagree with the above. However, he is correct; I
might end up in jail by the end of this month, although I hope not.

And there you have it everyone. according to several people in this
thread, which you can check for yourself, if you buy a FAMILY radio
service radio
with the intention of talking to your spouse, bring it home, plug it
in, turn it on to any one of the channels, listen to make sure no
one else is transmitting, and no one else is transmitting, and you
then transmit yourself on any one of the channels, you are breaking
the law by illegally
transmitting on police channels since yor local police department
might be using that as their exclusive police channel assigned to them
by
your local County Communications Commission.

It doesn't matter that no one else was transmitting on that FAMILY
radio service channel at the time. That FAMILY radio service channel
is reserved EXCLUSIELY for police use and ONLY for police use by your
local unfriendly County Communications Commission.

Which unlike the FederalCommunications Commission does not make the
assignments known until after an incident like the above happens, and
you're already on your way to jail for illegally interfering with ann
EXCLUSIVE police channel on the FAMILY Radio Service channels.

It also does not make any difference that you did not know it was an
exclusive police channel since no one was transmitting. It was and is
and "ignorance of the law is no excuse".

You should NOT be using FAMILY radio service channels for your FAMILY
communications needs. It is illegal to use FAMILY radio service
channels
for your family communications needs since ALL FAMILY radio service
channels are reserved for EXCLUSIVE police use and EXCLUSIVE EMS use
by your local unfriendly County Communications Commission.

The same can happen with any other CB band also, including 27 mhz CB.

If your local police department decides to use CB channel 22 as their
exclusive police channel that no one else is allowed to transmit on.

I wonder what would happen if some local police department decided to
use CB channel 19 as their exclusive police channel that no one else
is
allowed to transmit on?

even while the police aren't talking,justl istening fo hours, and then
arrest everyone they can that they hear talking on CB channel19
because CB
channel19 is an EXCLUSIVE police channel assigned to them theirselves
in that county.

O else assigned to them by their local County Communications
Commission.

What part of FAMILY in FAMILY Radio Service do the police not
understand??????????

It would be different if they were transmitting and someone purposely
interfered with them on amily radio servicve channels.

But when they're not transmitting over it and you have no idea at all
that they are using a FAMILY Radio Service channel as an EXCLUSIVE
police channel and get arrested for interfereing with police
communications when you call your spouse onn a FAMILY radio service
channel.

What part of FAMILY in Family Radio Service does yor local County
Communications Commission not understand????

What part of FAMILY in Family Radio Service does yor local EMS not
understand???

What part of FAMILY in Family Radio Service does your local police
department NOT
understand????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????
RHF
2009-01-18 04:14:55 UTC
Permalink
Post by radioguy
Post by Mike
Radioguy is going to make Bubba in prison VERY happy and satisfied.
He'll be cell block 9's favorite bitch.- Hide quoted text -
- Show quoted text -
I would like to disagree with the above. However, he is correct; I
might end up in jail by the end of this month, although I hope not.
And there you have it everyone. according to several people in this
thread, which you can check for yourself, if you buy a FAMILY radio
service radio
with the intention of talking to your spouse, bring it home, plug it
in, turn it on to any one of the  channels,  listen to make sure no
one else is transmitting, and no one else is transmitting, and you
then transmit yourself on any one of the channels,
- you are breaking the law by illegally transmitting on
- police channels since yor local police department
- might be using that as their exclusive police channel
- assigned to them by your local County Communications
- Commission.

"local County Communications Commission" ROTFL

blah, Blah. BLAH !

The 'locasl' Sonora City and Tuolumne Country
and CHP don't use any FRS channels around
here. All of what you are jabbering about would
appear to be another RadioGuy "Troll Story"
where 'you' are the Victim of some great plot
to deprive you of playing with you radios.

radioguy - stop your whining and simply
legally enjoy your radios ~ RHF
.
Post by radioguy
It doesn't matter that no one else was transmitting on that FAMILY
radio service channel at the time. That FAMILY radio service channel
is reserved EXCLUSIELY for police use and ONLY for police use by your
local unfriendly County Communications Commission.
Which unlike the FederalCommunications Commission does not make the
assignments known until after an incident like the above happens, and
you're already on your way to jail for illegally interfering with ann
EXCLUSIVE police channel on the FAMILY Radio Service channels.
It also does not make any difference that you did not know it was an
exclusive police channel since no one was transmitting. It was and is
and "ignorance  of the law is no excuse".
You should NOT be using FAMILY radio service channels for your FAMILY
communications needs. It is illegal to use FAMILY radio service
channels
for your family communications needs since ALL FAMILY radio service
channels are reserved for EXCLUSIVE police use and EXCLUSIVE EMS use
by your local unfriendly County Communications Commission.
The same can happen with any other CB band also, including 27 mhz CB.
If your local police department decides to use CB channel 22 as their
exclusive police channel that no one else is allowed to transmit on.
I wonder what would happen if some local police department decided to
use CB channel 19 as their exclusive police channel that no one else
is
allowed to transmit on?
even while the police aren't talking,justl istening fo hours, and then
arrest everyone they can that they hear talking on CB channel19
because CB
channel19 is an EXCLUSIVE police channel assigned to them theirselves
in that county.
O else assigned to them by their local County Communications
Commission.
What part of FAMILY in FAMILY Radio Service do the police not
understand??????????
It would be different if they were transmitting and someone purposely
interfered with them on amily radio servicve channels.
But when they're not transmitting over it and you have no idea at all
that they are using a FAMILY Radio Service channel as an EXCLUSIVE
police channel and get arrested for interfereing with police
communications when you call your spouse onn a FAMILY radio service
channel.
What part of FAMILY in Family Radio Service  does yor local County
Communications Commission not understand????
What part of FAMILY in Family Radio  Service does yor local EMS not
understand???
What part of FAMILY in Family Radio Service does your local police
department NOT
understand????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????
Bubba
2009-01-18 23:19:00 UTC
Permalink
On Sat, 17 Jan 2009 07:14:38 -0800 (PST), radioguy
Post by radioguy
Post by Mike
Radioguy is going to make Bubba in prison VERY happy and satisfied.
He'll be cell block 9's favorite bitch.- Hide quoted text -
- Show quoted text -
I would like to disagree with the above. However, he is correct; I
might end up in jail by the end of this month, although I hope not.
Oh Radioguy, I can't wait to hump your rump. Keep talking stupid like
you are, and I'll be drilling for mud sooner than you think.

Bubba
RHF
2009-01-16 02:38:26 UTC
Permalink
Post by radioguy
Post by radioguy
Post by Mike
Post by h***@att.net
Some of us hams use radios that are WIDE OPEN!
Try talking to FEMA with FRS.
Which is illegal as your hammy radios are not FCC type accepted for
operation outside of the hammy bands.
The EMS service in my area uses one of the frs-only channels
Both for dspatch and communications.
And the.police use one of the frs-only
For communicationm\ns involving following vehicles and reading the
license plate numbers of the vehicles  over the air.
Is it illegal for me to possess my frs.gmrs radios since they are
capable of transmtting on frequencie used by the police and ems??
Is it illegal for me to transmit on those frs-only channels since
they're police and ems channels?????
The federal FCC rules say they are shared channels that anyone may
use.
However, there have already been people in other cities and other
states arrested for illegally transmitting over police channels when
those police
channels were on the frs channels.
It seems like federal law did not trump local and state law in those
cases despite what 99.99 percent of the hams on here have said.
And even when people can get out of it, it still costs them in court
costs and lawyers fees.
The kind of money that I do not have and would not be able to get out
of in such a case.
So yes you can be fined, found guilty and put in jail for legally
transmitting on your frs/gmrs radio even when you don't hear anyone
else transmitting
on that channel since you are illegally transmitting on a police
channel or ems channel by doing so (as far as local police, local
government and some states are concerned).
Even if it is one of the frs-only channels (eight through fourteen on
the radios I've seen).
I'm not sure if what I heard is my local town or one of the other
towns very close to me.
However, the police and ems are definitely using the frs-only channels
as a police channel and an ems channel. (two different channels, one
each that I have heard so far).
According to the FCC rules I've read, that is legal for them to use as
such since frs may be used by anyone including businesses or by anyone
period.
Bt once again, (concerning the arrests of people for transmitting on
frs-only channels) what happened to federal law always trumps local
and state law???
RadioGuy,
More Ham Radio This and Ham Radio That
- - - yada, Yada. YADA !
The-Bottom-Line : It is Clearly Illegal for 'you' to
knowingly Interfere with Official Public Service
Radio Operations on Any Frequency [.]
- - - Being an Amateur Radio Operator has it limits.
Plus - It is Clearly Illegal for you to knowingly
Interfere with {get-in-the-way-of} Official Public
Service Operations at Any Location [.]
- - - Being an Involved Citizen has it limits.
now go and enjoy your radios ~ RHF
-ps- please stay-out of the way of public
service employees doing their jobs.
 .- Hide quoted text -
- Show quoted text -
I did not say it's legal to interfere with the police. It's not. I
even said the FCC rules say that we're not allowed to interfere with
the police.
However, I do not consider transmitting on a frs channel that no one
else is talking on at the time as "interfering with the police" even
if the police
say so because they think the shared frs channels are their own
private police channels.
What if I had never heard them on there in the first place, which
could have happened since I very rarely have my frs radios on.
I turn to frs channel 8, hear no one talking, so transmit to the other
person I'm talking to, and get arrested for "illegally transmitting on
a police channel".
I try to get out of it by truthfully saying I didn't know it's a
police channel.
They and the court then come back with "Ignorance of the law is no
excuse".
But wait, the federal FCC rules says the channels are for everyone as
long as no interference is caused.
However, even though the police were not talking at the time, but were
listening, they consider it as interference being caused to their own
private
family radio servvice police channel.
While I consider it as interference not happening since no
conversations were on the channel at the time I was listening and
transmitting.
Once again, what happened to federal law trumps all local and state
laws?
I'm no rich enough to fight it in court.
So you're basically saying that no one in the general public is
allowed to use the frs-only channels even though the fedeal FCC says
the can, since
a number of public safety agencies inclding the police and ems have
decided to use the frs-only channels as their own private publicv
safety channels.
EMS channel 8. Police channel 14. Etcetera.
This forces the general public to illegally use channels 1-7 and 15
throguh 22, since they can't use channels 7 through 14 without getting
arrested by
 the police for illegally using police channels.
I wonder what John Wilkerson would say about that.
Of course, the public would also be fined and arrested by the FCC  and
federal marshalls for illegally using channela 1 through 7 and 15
through 22.
Another one of RadioGuy's absurd "Troll Story"s
-aka- 'war and peace' on the internet ~ RHF
.
RHF
2009-01-15 20:07:17 UTC
Permalink
Post by radioguy
Post by Mike
Post by h***@att.net
Some of us hams use radios that are WIDE OPEN!
Try talking to FEMA with FRS.
Which is illegal as your hammy radios are not FCC type accepted for
operation outside of the hammy bands.
The EMS service in my area uses one of the frs-only channels
Both for dspatch and communications.
And the.police use one of the frs-only
For communicationm\ns involving following vehicles and reading the
license plate numbers of the vehicles  over the air.
Is it illegal for me to possess my frs.gmrs radios since they are
capable of transmtting on frequencie used by the police and ems??
Is it illegal for me to transmit on those frs-only channels since
they're police and ems channels?????
The federal FCC rules say they are shared channels that anyone may
use.
However, there have already been people in other cities and other
states arrested for illegally transmitting over police channels when
those police
channels were on the frs channels.
It seems like federal law did not trump local and state law in those
cases despite what 99.99 percent of the hams on here have said.
And even when people can get out of it, it still costs them in court
costs and lawyers fees.
The kind of money that I do not have and would not be able to get out
of in such a case.
So yes you can be fined, found guilty and put in jail for legally
transmitting on your frs/gmrs radio even when you don't hear anyone
else transmitting
on that channel since you are illegally transmitting on a police
channel or ems channel by doing so (as far as local police, local
government and some states are concerned).
Even if it is one of the frs-only channels (eight through fourteen on
the radios I've seen).
I'm not sure if what I heard is my local town or one of the other
towns very close to me.
However, the police and ems are definitely using the frs-only channels
as a police channel and an ems channel. (two different channels, one
each that I have heard so far).
According to the FCC rules I've read, that is legal for them to use as
such since frs may be used by anyone including businesses or by anyone
period.
Bt once again, (concerning the arrests of people for transmitting on
frs-only channels) what happened to federal law always trumps local
and state law???
RadioGuy,
More Ham Radio This and Ham Radio That
- - - yada, Yada. YADA !

The-Bottom-Line : It is Clearly Illegal for 'you' to
knowingly Interfere with Official Public Service
Radio Operations on Any Frequency [.]
- - - Being an Amateur Radio Operator has it limits.

Plus - It is Clearly Illegal for you to knowingly
Interfere with {get-in-the-way-of} Official Public
Service Operations at Any Location [.]
- - - Being an Involved Citizen has it limits.

now go and enjoy your radios ~ RHF
-ps- please stay-out of the way of public
service employees doing their jobs.
.
RHF
2009-01-12 03:50:40 UTC
Permalink
Post by h***@att.net
On Sun, 11 Jan 2009 12:12:40 -0800 (PST), RHF
Post by RHF
Post by Ian Jackson
Post by Dave
Post by RHF
Honestly - If everyone wanted and needed Emergency
Communications and the US Government wanted it's
Citizens to have Emergency Communications.
Then Every US Household and Every Car and Truck
1 - Family Radio Service (FRS)
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Family_Radio_Service
2 - General Mobile Radio Service (GMRS)
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/General_Mobile_Radio_Service
3 - Citizens' Band (CB) Radio
 - Will you quit being a dipshit?  Have you ever been in an emergency
e.g.
- flash flood or wildfire?  Do you think there are enough paid
emergency
- personnel to cover every street closure?  To spot weather?  To relay
- information to the media?
-
- Not everyone lives in the middle of nowhere.
 Dave,
 When the Power Goes "Off" for an Hour or More : Then
* No{Where} AC for the TV / Radio
* No{Where} AC for the Internet / PC
* No{Where} AC for the Lights / Heater
* No{Where} AC for the Microwave / Coffee Pot
* No{Where} AC for the Refrigerator / Stove
* No{Where} AC for the Washer / Dryer
* * The 'basic' Home Phone may work but the
Cordless Phone and Cellphone just might not.
The only place most people have with News,
Lights and Heat is Setting in their Car or Truck
with the Engine Running and that is not good
to do in their Garages. {Best Done Outdoors
in the Drive Way and Off the Street.}
"Then Every US Household and Every Car and Truck
 1 - Family Radio Service (FRS)
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Family_Radio_Service
 2 - General Mobile Radio Service (GMRS)
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/General_Mobile_Radio_Service
 3 - Citizens' Band (CB) Radio
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Citizens%27_band_radio
Not everyone is comfortable on a two-way radio.
In a real emergency, the would soon learn to be 'comfortable'!
- An FRS radio goes a few miles.
- I can reach all of North America 24/7.
- Amateur Radio is often the only
- infrastructure that survives a calamity.
And if the local Hams in a Neighborhood had a Plan
to go to the local Neighborhood Fire Stations and
not only man Amateur Radio by FRS, GMRS and
CB then they would be Helping All the People in
Need within the '"Few [Square] Miles" of their own
local Neighborhood.
The-Bottom-Line : Helping Your Neighbors In
A Local Emergency Does Not Require a Nation
Wide ComLine. Reliable Local Communications
Is What Is Required To Identify People In-Need
And Get Them H-E-L-P !
Lets See 5~10 Amateur Radio Operators -or-
50~200 Local Citizens with FRS, GMRS and
CB Radios in each Local Neighborhood: I Say
Go With The Local Citizens.
idtars ~ RHF
.
- Some of us hams use radios that are WIDE OPEN!
- Try talking to FEMA with FRS.

That is simply Bad Planning on FEMA and the
Local Responders parts.

1 - A Localized Plan that includes HAMs and FRS,
GMRS and CB Radios for a Total Neighborhood
Emergency Communications System.

2 - Put Scanners, FRS, GMRS and CB Radios in every
Local Fire Station.

3 - Put FRS, GMRS and CB Radios in every American
Home.

4 - Put a 10 Watt LPFM Emergency Alert Transmitter
in every Local Fire Station so that every American Home
an tune into their Local Neighborhood's Emergency News
Put a Ham on the Mic. Better require every Local Five
Department to have 1/3rd of their Firemen to have an
FCC Amateur Radio License; and Trained as Emergency
Communications Operators in the use of FRS, GMRS
and CB Radios and the 10 Watt LPFM Emergency Alert
Transmitter.

5 - Make It Mandatory that Every American Household
has a Crank-Up {Battery} AM/FM Radio for Emergency
Neighborhood Communications News.

idtars ~ RHF
.
.
Dave
2009-01-12 14:07:15 UTC
Permalink
RHF wrote:
.
Post by RHF
5 - Make It Mandatory that Every American Household
has a Crank-Up {Battery} AM/FM Radio for Emergency
Neighborhood Communications News.
idtars ~ RHF
.
Right next to the smoke detector?
RHF
2009-01-12 14:27:20 UTC
Permalink
.
- - 5 - Make It Mandatory that Every American Household
- - has a Crank-Up {Battery} AM/FM Radio for Emergency
- - Neighborhood Communications News.
- -
- - idtars ~ RHF

- Right next to the smoke detector?

Dave - Yeah - That would do.

-ps- Moderate 'cranking' of the Radio please
don't want to set the Smoke Detector OFF !
.
Steve Stone
2009-01-12 17:59:45 UTC
Permalink
Do you think we can get Obama to pay for this from bail out funds ?
Post by RHF
- Some of us hams use radios that are WIDE OPEN!
- Try talking to FEMA with FRS.
That is simply Bad Planning on FEMA and the
Local Responders parts.
1 - A Localized Plan that includes HAMs and FRS,
GMRS and CB Radios for a Total Neighborhood
Emergency Communications System.
2 - Put Scanners, FRS, GMRS and CB Radios in every
Local Fire Station.
3 - Put FRS, GMRS and CB Radios in every American
Home.
4 - Put a 10 Watt LPFM Emergency Alert Transmitter
in every Local Fire Station so that every American Home
an tune into their Local Neighborhood's Emergency News
Put a Ham on the Mic. Better require every Local Five
Department to have 1/3rd of their Firemen to have an
FCC Amateur Radio License; and Trained as Emergency
Communications Operators in the use of FRS, GMRS
and CB Radios and the 10 Watt LPFM Emergency Alert
Transmitter.
5 - Make It Mandatory that Every American Household
has a Crank-Up {Battery} AM/FM Radio for Emergency
Neighborhood Communications News.
idtars ~ RHF
.
.
RHF
2009-01-11 16:14:34 UTC
Permalink
Post by RHF
Post by RHF
Honestly - If everyone wanted and needed Emergency
Communications and the US Government wanted it's
Citizens to have Emergency Communications.
Then Every US Household and Every Car and Truck
1 - Family Radio Service (FRS)
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Family_Radio_Service
2 - General Mobile Radio Service (GMRS)
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/General_Mobile_Radio_Service
3 - Citizens' Band (CB) Radio
- Will you quit being a dipshit?  Have you ever been in an emergency
e.g.
- flash flood or wildfire?  Do you think there are enough paid
emergency
- personnel to cover every street closure?  To spot weather?  To relay
- information to the media?
-
- Not everyone lives in the middle of nowhere.
Dave,
When the Power Goes "Off" for an Hour or More : Then
* No{Where} AC for the TV / Radio
* No{Where} AC for the Internet / PC
* No{Where} AC for the Lights / Heater
* No{Where} AC for the Microwave / Coffee Pot
* No{Where} AC for the Refrigerator / Stove
* No{Where} AC for the Washer / Dryer
* * The 'basic' Home Phone may work but the
Cordless Phone and Cellphone just might not.
The only place most people have with News,
Lights and Heat is Setting in their Car or Truck
with the Engine Running and that is not good
to do in their Garages. {Best Done Outdoors
in the Drive Way and Off the Street.}
"Then Every US Household and Every Car and Truck
1 - Family Radio Service (FRS)
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Family_Radio_Service
2 - General Mobile Radio Service (GMRS)
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/General_Mobile_Radio_Service
3 - Citizens' Band (CB) Radio
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Citizens%27_band_radio
- Not everyone is comfortable on a two-way radio.

Dave,

D'Oh ! -if- they can Do a Telephone, Cellphone and
Internet-Phone they can 'adjust' to a 2-Way Radio.

=PS= If they have the Walkie-Talkie feature on their
Cellphone they can do 2-Way A-OK.

Integrated Digital Enhanced Network (iDEN)
-aka- "Direct-Connect" -aka- Push-To-Talk (PTT)
http://electronics.howstuffworks.com/question530.htm
http://www.pcworld.com/article/109433/here_comes_the_walkietalkie_cell_phone.html
http://www.wisegeek.com/what-should-i-consider-when-buying-a-cell-phone-walkie-talkie.htm

PLUS : Buy-One & Try-One & Use-One {Be Prepared}

One of these may be the First Step for many/most
now a days to consider the possibilities of becoming
an Amateur Radio {Ham} Operator.

1 - Family Radio Service (FRS)
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Family_Radio_Service

2 - General Mobile Radio Service (GMRS)
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/General_Mobile_Radio_Service

3 - Citizens' Band (CB) Radio
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Citizens%27_band_radio

idtars ~ RHF
.
.
BDK
2009-01-10 19:43:31 UTC
Permalink
In article <48a2b754-605f-4be8-84ac-
***@z28g2000prd.googlegroups.com>, ***@yahoo.com
says...
Post by radioguy
These people didn't care that hams help provide emergency services.
They still wanted the ham tower completely gone.
I wonder who won. Click on
http://74.125.95.132/search?q=cache:aCVpkB3Ki2oJ:www.antennazoning.com/docs/N1CIV-060105-Valley-News.pdf+%22ham+radio%22%2B%22interference%22%2B%22neighbors%22&hl=en&ct=clnk&cd=50&gl=us
The neighbors seem pretty irrational.
--
BDK

BDK Klan leader?
kOOk Magnet!
NJJ CLUB #1
Shillmaster
Telamon
2009-01-10 23:15:23 UTC
Permalink
In article
Post by radioguy
These people didn't care that hams help provide emergency services.
They still wanted the ham tower completely gone.
I wonder who won. Click on
<http://74.125.95.132/search?q=cache:aCVpkB3Ki2oJ:www.antennazoning.com/docs/N1CIV-060105-Valley-News.pdf+%22ham+radio%22%2B%22interference%22%2B%22neighbors%22&hl=en&ct=clnk&cd=50&gl=us>
The trend is for the stupid clueless masses to win.
--
Telamon
Ventura, California
m***@yahoo.com
2009-01-22 19:50:57 UTC
Permalink
Post by radioguy
These people didn't care that hams help provide emergency services.
They still wanted the ham tower completely gone.
I wonder who won. Click on
http://74.125.95.132/search?q=cache:aCVpkB3Ki2oJ:www.antennazoning.co...
http://nimbusters.org/forum/read.php?board=8&id=680253
an old friend
2009-01-23 04:47:51 UTC
Permalink
On Jan 22, 2:50 pm, ***@yahoo.com wrote:
get a life
RHF
2009-01-23 18:49:52 UTC
Permalink
Post by an old friend
get a life
-was- These people didn't care hams help with emergency services

The Amateur Radio Service Is {Hams are} Obscure in the USA
-so- Why Should The US Public Care What Hams Do ?

In the USA Amateur Radio Operators {Hams} make
up about 0.25% of the US Population.
-meaning- If each Ham is known as a "Ham" by 9
'other' people that are not Hams :
That only adds up to 2.5%
-meaning- That the "Other" 97.5% of Americans do
not know that Amateur Radio Operators {Hams}
even exist.
-conclusion- If People Don't Know That You Exist
and Thus Don't Know What Good You Do :
Therefore They Don't Care About You and the
Good You Do [.] ~ RHF
.
.
d***@gmail.com
2009-01-23 20:23:14 UTC
Permalink
On Fri, 23 Jan 2009 10:49:52 -0800 (PST), RHF
Post by RHF
Post by an old friend
get a life
-was- These people didn't care hams help with emergency services
The Amateur Radio Service Is {Hams are} Obscure in the USA
-so- Why Should The US Public Care What Hams Do ?
well the oremise is wrong they should not care what we do by and large
they should care about what we can do
~ RHF
2009-01-29 23:43:45 UTC
Permalink
Post by an old friend
get a life
- - -was- These people didn't care hams help with emergency services
-
- The Amateur Radio Service Is {Hams are} Obscure in the USA
- -so- Why Should The US Public Care What Hams Do ?
-
- In the USA Amateur Radio Operators {Hams} make
- up about 0.25% of the US Population.
- -meaning- If each Ham is known as a "Ham" by 9
- 'other' people that are not Hams :
- That only adds up to 2.5%
- -meaning- That the "Other" 97.5% of Americans do
- not know that Amateur Radio Operators {Hams}
- even exist.
- -conclusion- If People Don't Know That You Exist
- and Thus Don't Know What Good You Do :
- Therefore They Don't Care About You and the
- Good You Do [.] ~RHF
-  .
-  .

Heard on KVML-AM 1450 kHz @ 21:21 UTC on
http://www.kvmlam.com/index.php
28 JAN 2009 a Radio Adz for the Amateur Radio
[Ham] Service by the ARRL during the Nationally
Syndicated Sean Hannity Radio Show.
http://www.hannity.com/
.
Way To Go ARRL ! - Get out there and Promote
the Amateur Radio [Ham] Service to the Public.
.
Sort of like the First and Second Amendments
Joined Together :
* The Right to Use the Amateur Radio to Help
Your Fellow US Citizens During Emergencies.
* The Right to Bear Arms to Protect Yourself
and Your Fellow US Citizens in Emergencies.

IMHO - The ARRL should be Advertising in the
NRA Publications for like minded patriotic US
http://www.nrapublications.org/index.asp
Citizens who would find being an Amateur Radio
Operator an interesting Hobby and they would
be strong advocates for the HAM cause.

once again - 'way to go arrl' ~ RHF
.
.
RHF
2009-01-29 23:46:10 UTC
Permalink
Post by ~ RHF
Post by an old friend
get a life
- - -was- These people didn't care hams help with emergency services
-
- The Amateur Radio Service Is {Hams are} Obscure in the USA
- -so- Why Should The US Public Care What Hams Do ?
-
- In the USA Amateur Radio Operators {Hams} make
- up about 0.25% of the US Population.
- -meaning- If each Ham is known as a "Ham" by 9
- That only adds up to 2.5%
- -meaning- That the "Other" 97.5% of Americans do
- not know that Amateur Radio Operators {Hams}
- even exist.
- -conclusion- If People Don't Know That You Exist
- Therefore They Don't Care About You and the
- Good You Do [.] ~RHF
-  .
-  .
- Heard on KVML-AM 1450 kHz @ 21:21 UTC on
- http://www.kvmlam.com/index.php
- 28 JAN 2009 a Radio Adz for the Amateur Radio
- [Ham] Service by the ARRL during the Nationally
- Syndicated Sean Hannity Radio Show.http://www.hannity.com/
-  .
- Way To Go ARRL ! - Get out there and Promote
- the Amateur Radio [Ham] Service to the Public.
-  .
- Sort of like the First and Second Amendments
- Joined Together :
- * The Right to Use the Amateur Radio to Help
- Your Fellow US Citizens During Emergencies.
- * The Right to Bear Arms to Protect Yourself
- and Your Fellow US Citizens in Emergencies.
-
- IMHO - The ARRL should be Advertising in the
- NRA Publications for like minded patriotic US
- http://www.nrapublications.org/index.asp
- Citizens who would find being an Amateur Radio
- Operator an interesting Hobby and they would
- be strong advocates for the HAM cause.
-
- once again - 'way to go arrl' ~ RHF
-  .
-  .

Loading...